for: performance, everyday ride-comfort, tech. reliability; which is best: AudiTT, Cayman, BMW M3, or SLK?

Favorite Answer

These would vary greatly in price and performance. I bought an M3 convert and dumped a Boxster S after my son was born, so we could put a childseat in the back. In my case, the 2nd row of seats was the deciding factor. But the performance of the M3 is also significantly better.

Of the 4 mentioned, only the M3 can handle more than 2 people. My 2002 M3 has a rough ride compared to my wife's X5 (naturally) but it is still a very drivable car for every day. I suspect the same is true for a TT, SLK or Cayman, but the M3 is a real car vs. a tiny sports car. Also, it blows away the TT and SLK in performance --- by a longshot -- and is about equal to that of the Cayman.

The M3 is refined, whereas the Cayman is probably like the Boxster S I had, which was not practical for day-to-day use. It was great to jump in when I got home from work -- but a nightmare to drive to work the few times I attempted. In contrast, I drive the M3 to work every day....Show more

I like 'em all but would probably say the BMW M3 for everyday ride/comfort and reliability. None of these cars are going to be squishy comfortable like a Town Car and none has shown great reliability lately, but if I had to choose one from your requirements, I'd go with the M3. And I own and enjoy Porsches....Show more

I'd take the M3, then the Cayman, SLK, and the Audi TT... All are great tho....Show more

Go for Mercedes Benz SLK 320 awesome piece of metal....Show more

I would positively choose the M3...Show more