A "hard" question about the number 10...?

Actually, I have no clue whether this is hard or not...

Prove or disprove:
10 cannot be written as the difference of squares of rational numbers.

2008-10-15T14:33:31Z

Awww... bummer.

Oh well, back to the drawing board then (I was so focused on trying to prove it that I missed the obvious @_@)

2008-10-15T14:48:06Z

... maybe I've forgotten what a minimal polynomial is... heheh...

2008-10-15T15:05:14Z

Actually, thanks for the responses, guys. I'd been trying to prove a polynomial was minimal. My work led me to this statement, but it didn't seem to work (now I see why it wasn't).

I just looked back at my work and realized I have a stronger assumption I can make that changes the problem to the statement that √2 and √3 are irrational, which is easy.

Again, thanks for the answers, guys.

kolibrizas2008-10-15T14:31:09Z

Favorite Answer

x^2-y^2=10 => (x-y)(x+y)=10 => here we just guess that 2*5 is 10, so
x-y=2
x+y=5
here we get x=3.5, y=1.5
so i prooved..
quite simple, huh?

by the way, the same would be if we take 4*2.5=10
x-y=2.5
x+y=4
x=3.25 y=0.75

unsing this way, you can get more...

Steiner2008-10-15T14:51:40Z

Let b ne any positive integer.

x² - y² = n
(x + y)(x - y) = n

A possible solution is

x + y = n
x - y = 1

This gives

x = (n +1)/2
y = ( n-1)/2

Siince n is an integer, x and y are rational. Hence, every positive integer (actually, every integer) can be given by the difference of 2 squares of rational numbers.

Anonymous2008-10-15T14:18:59Z

no idea but i do know n! cannot be written as the difference of two integer squares