Why is there bigotry in my friends Past-Lives-Regression group?

An old friend has recently become convinced he has lived before previously after attending a Reincarnation lecture with his new dingbat girlfriend. He even joined a small group who meet to discuss such topics. However, there is a problem. In this group there is a reincarnated Cleopatra, A reincarnated Hannibal, two reincarnated Alexanders, and several other famous historical figures. But he has come to the conclusion he is the reincarnation of a dude named Seamus, an Irish potato farmer.
Not very glorious, of course. Now all the other folks look down their reincarnated noses at him?
What gives? Is their a bias in the Reincarnation community against those who were not super famous in their past lives? And how come so many in this community were Abe Lincoln's in the past, and now they work at Wal-Mart?

2009-04-20T12:28:29Z

Thanks Joaquin

Anonymous2009-04-20T12:30:01Z

Favorite Answer

I'm a reincarnated sex slave from Constantinople. Or was it Istanbul?

Oh, well, so long ago the particulars elude me.

Anonymous2016-04-03T07:35:03Z

In Past Lives, Future Lives there is instructions for doing a regression. I did it on a friend and another friend did it to me a few times. I have no idea if it really worked or my brain was creating stories for me. The friend I did it to was a girl in the 1960s who fell in with a bad crowd and they accidentaly killed someone. I was a Victorian street child who was also mute and I "couldn't" speak when I was asked questions. Another one was that I was the daughter of a well off family that supported the Revolution. And the other one that I remember was that I was a solider in the trenches of France during the first World War but I kept saying that I wasn't allowed to say where I was. So none of my lives were anything special, just average lives. I have a degree in history, so who knows where it all came from. The feeling is sort of like when you are about to fall asleep but are still concious and aware of what's going on, but can't really do anything about it. Keep in mind that not everyone can be hypnotized, so don't be disappointed if you aren't. But if you do, have fun and don't take it too seriously.

Stella2009-04-20T14:16:32Z

Ok, whoever's running this group is a fraud. There are legitimate past-life-regression specialists out there, but this isn't one of them. Anyone interested in this kind of thing: run away screaming from anyone who tells you that you were someone famous. Statistically, it's unlikely and these people are just trying to get your money by massaging your ego.

And how can you have two people who were both Alexander? How does anyone in this group take that seriously? LOL Oh let me guess, the guy uses the "fractured soul" theory, so there could be thousands of "pieces" of Alexander's soul out there. Give me a break!

At any rate, the real value in PLR is getting a meaningful archetypal narrative that helps you in some way in your *current* life. It doesn't matter so much whether or not the story is factually true (some have been able to verify them); it matters whether the themes of the story can help you get perspective on your current life problems. That's the real value in this kind of work IMO. Say a woman "finds out" in regression that she died drowning in a past life. Does it matter if she really did? No, but if it helps her overcome her fear of water in this life, then the regression was worth it.

Anonymous2009-04-20T12:23:13Z

Is there a reincarnated Jacqueline Kennedy?

Pete2009-04-20T12:29:38Z

I think the super famous are just making that stuff up. I mean... How can there be two Alexanders the Great eh?

Show more answers (6)