Question about starting a new tank with old filter with Nitrates.?

I have a tank that has been set up for about a month. It was started with some new and some older water from another tank. It is my fry tank, and yes it is overcrowded, but I'm working on that. I vacuumed the gravel the other day and there wasn't much waste (surprisingly), but my nitrates are high. I know that is probably a combo of being new and overcrowded. My question is, would it be okay to start a new tank with the filter from this tank with nitrates? Since it is new water do you think it would hurt anything, or do you think it would help with cycling process? Please don't scold me on overcrowdedness of the tank, it will be taken care of within the next couple of days ;o) Thanks

2009-06-14T11:26:14Z

I was basically just wondering if I could start a new tank with an old filter with nitrates. The old filter would be coming from a tank that has high nitrates and I was just basically wondering if it would hurt the new tank and fish.

SS112009-06-14T10:35:50Z

Favorite Answer

go ahead, use that tank , if it's new water , clean gravel , clean filter then u may use it . i have a tank at home with 16 fish , the tank is real big , the problem that i had was that the water is getting green every week , i realized that i had to clean the filter and while i was looking at the filter it was covered with dirt and bacterias, u gotta watch out from that.

scootrkitz2009-06-14T10:43:02Z

Typically, it takes at least 30 days for a new tank to cycle...you can certainly use an old filter to start a new tank, but don't be too hasty to put any fish in it for 30 days...it will look good for about 3 or 4 days...then it will look awful and cloudy for about 2 weeks...magically, after about 30 days, the water will clear and will be ready for fish..introduce a few at a time...no need to overload a new bio-system.
There is more beneficial bacteria in the gravel and rocks than in the water, but every little bit will help to "seed" the new tank.
Be patient and resist adding any fish for at least 30 days...unless you want to cycle the tank with a few inexpensive goldfish or guppies...not a bad way to go, either. You can put them in on day one and feed them lightly....but give the tank 30 days to stabilize.

Tio2009-06-14T10:58:38Z

would you not want the fish in there with and old filter ?the bacteria is in the filter already and without the fish in the tank producing waste ti feed the bacteria it would make sense the bacteria would die out.old filter and old water and gravel the tank should be ready for fish right away