Chronicles of Narnia vs Lord of the Rings?

Favorite Answer

Why on earth would they be fighting? You must have an... er... open mind to be mixing those two worlds together. That's like saying Hogwarts would go on a rampage in Terabithia!...Show more

I can't see Lucy and Frodo fighting, but if they did, Lucy would win. She may be all heart, but she is scrappier.

Edmund versus Samwise would be an interesting fight. Samwise was the tougher customer, but Edmund was learned in sword fighting and true combat. Therefore, Edmund wins. (If it happened to be a fistfight, Samwise would win.)

Susan versus Legolas - another interesting fight. Susan isn't truly a fighter, so Legolas would win easily.

Caspian versus Boromir...hmm...they are both good at fighting, but I think Boromir has the edge. He's a bit more battle-hardened than Caspian.

Peter versus Aragorn is a relatively easy one to call: Aragorn would win. Peter, though he was trained and knew how to fight, was not first and foremost a warrior; Aragorn was. He was also used to rough conditions, unlike Peter.

Aslan versus Gandalf is another easy choice, in my opinion: Aslan, without even breaking a sweat. Gandalf was powerful, but Aslan was power; the difference is in the one having might and the other being mighty, in and of himself.

Jadis versus Sauron is a difficult one to determine. They were both powerful and crafty, but, in the end, I believe Sauron would have the edge. In this case, the analogy might be that Jadis worships the demon, while Sauron -is- the demon.

Fun question....Show more

Interesting...

Lucy vs. Frodo - I have to say that Lucy might win simply because I can't see Frodo harming a little girl (Frodo didn't even want anyone to kill Saruman after he overtook and pretty much destroyed the Shire, so I can't see him willing to fight a child). If Frodo did go out of character and did agree to fight, though, I think he would win.

Edmund vs. Samwise - Well, Samwise ends up being one tough, determined hobbit, so I think I might put my money on him.

Susan vs. Legolas - Honestly, I don't think Susan would stand a chance.

Caspian vs. Boromir - In the book, Caspian really wasn't portrayed as overly intellectual and he also wasn't that much of a fighter, so I think Boromir would win. Also, while Boromir did have loyalty issues, he was still a pretty capable man.

Peter vs. Aragorn - Peter may have ended up being a fairly capable, mighty king, but I really don't think he would last long in a fight against Aragorn.

Aslan vs. Gandalf - This is a tough one. I really don't know...I might lean a little more toward Gandalf, though, because he is a very talented, powerful wizard...

Jadis vs. Sauron - Sauron. Jadis is one evil woman, but Sauron is a very, very evil being with a lot of very, very evil minions.

I pretty much think that The Lord of the Rings characters are very talented and capable. Except for the fact that I really can't see Frodo harming a child and except for the fact that I think Aslan and Gandalf are both very powerful, my votes go for the LOTR characters.

Best wishes!...Show more

1. Lucy--Frodo is but a hobbit while Lucy is valiant and never lost faith
2. Edmund--Edmund matured immensely
3. Legolas--because Legolas is around 2000 years old and has more practice and experience; but Susan's archery skills are legendary in the books
4. Boromir--he's older
5. Peter--he's the High King
6. Aslan--because he's Aslan
7. Sauron--he's more evil and scary...Show more

Well, Frodo doesn't like to fight, and fighting a girl I really think that he would flatout refuse, after all he didn't even want Sauruman to be killed after he tried to kill him!
Well, if Edmund was in his "bad" time frame where he's with the Witch, and was for some reason after Frodo, Sam would win, but after years of training and living in Narnia, adult Edmund would most likely when, but then again, Sam defeated Shelob - NEVER UNDERESTIMATE A HOBBIT!!
Legolas, sorry, but he's an elf.
Probably Boromir, he's had his whole life as a well trained Gondorian captain.
Depends, if you mean like High King Peter, when he was an adult, maybe a tie, not sure.
Aslan, no competition. Now Aslan vs. Illuvatar would be a better match.
Sauron, sorry, but he's like really bad.

Interesting "fight". Thanks for posting....Show more