As of now, in your 3 most favorite weight divisions, which boxers are the most overlooked? Or the most underrated? How about the most underlooked (if that's a word)? Or the most overrated? You tell me.
Ring King
Favorite Answer
Welterweight:
Underrated - Luis Collazo
Overrated - Andre Berto
Jr.Featherweight:
Underrated - Jhonny Gonzalez
Overrated - Celestino Caballero
Super Middleweight:
Underrated - Librado Andrade
Overrated - Carl Froch
Anonymous
Welterweight- Overrated-Floyd Mayweather
Underated Miguel Cotto
Jr. Flyweights- Overrated -Rodel Mayol
Underrated - Ulisis Solis
Jr. Featherweights- Overrated- Celestino Caballero
Underrated- Juan Manuel Lopez
Anonymous
Welterweight: OR- Margarito ~ Although he may have been an elite Welterweight prior to the Cotto fight, the guy has been exposed with all the plaster nonsense and trashing Mosley gave him.
UR- Joshua Clottey ~ This guy will make any other Welterweight look bad, be it a win or a lost, which was seen in the Cotto fight.
Junior Welterweight: OR- Andreas Kotelnik ~ He just got exposed by the faster and more youthful Amir Khan and the win over Maidana was a fluke if you ask me. Victor Ortiz would have fit in the category too.
UR- Marcos Maidana ~ He lost a hometown decision to to Kotelnik, and exposed an overhyped Victor Ortiz. But he is still just an interim champion, hopefully he gets another shot at the regular world title.
Junior Bantamweight: OR- Vic Darchinyan ~ The guy only has one punch, and if he can't land it, it is all over for him. "Smart" boxers would easily dispose of him. Those who have a game plan to solve that unorthodox style of him.
UR- Z Gorres ~ This guy should be a world champion right now. He put Darchinyan and Montiel to the brink of their defenses. He is lookin for a Montiel rematch, hopefully the guy gets another crack at a title.
Anonymous
1. Welterweight
Underrated: Miguel Cotto, Joshua Clottey, Isaac Hlatswayo.
Overrated: Antonio Margarito, Zab Judah, Floyd Mayweather jr.
2. Featherweight
Underrated: Chris John, Ryo Li Lee, Yuriorkis Gamboa
Overrated: Rocky Juarez, Elio Rojas, Cristobal Cruz
3. Junior Featherweight
Underrated: Celestino Caballero, Poonsawat Kratingaenggym, Toshiaki Nishioka.
Overrated: Jhonny Gonzalez, Juan Manuel Lopez, Bernard Dunne
Edit: Hey bro, would you be kind enough to lay your input in this question. Thank you!
http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;_ylt=AjZrNmDly4U4OsvQ7U2GYf36DH1G;_ylv=3?qid=20090907171147AATuHIz
Macehualli Moquexquitzahuiani
Underrated
Eddie Chambers, Heavyweight
Hasegawa Hozumi, Bantamweight
Toshiaki Nishioka, Junior Featherweight
Overrated
Andre Berto, Welterweight
Antonio Margarito, Welterweight
Nikolai Valuev, Russia