Who will be eliminated next from American Idol?

Favorite Answer

Andrew Garcia unless he can step it up this week. Should have been gone this week, but Alex Lambert bit the bullet for him instead.

My Predicted Boot Order for AI9

12th- Andrew Garcia - Struggled thus far. Needs to step up, and I dont think he will.
11th- Paige Miles - Forgettable, and lost in the crowd.
--Tour Group--
10th- Katie Stevens - Average thus far. No signs of her stepping up any time soon. A sob story and a cute face can only get you so far.
9th- Aaron Kelly - If this teen can stop sounding like a thirty something country singer, he might have a shot. He wont though.
8th- Lacey Brown - Somewhat forgettable. Decent voice. Too bad.
7th- Didi Benami - American Idol can only put up with a decent country singer for so long. Unless she can become more Pop like Carrie Underwood did.
6th- Tim Urban - His luck runs out as his singing ability catches up to him.
5th- Michael Lynche - Big, fun and likeable. However, not cut out to be the next Idol.
4th- Casey James- The upset of the season everyone will be talking about.
3rd- Crystal Bowersox - Great musician and will get far. Just not cut out to be the next Idol.

Finale

Runner-up - Siobhan Magnus - Likeable young girl with a mysterious, yet calming voice. She will do well, however she will fall just short.

Winner - Lee DeWyze - Likeable young singer/songwriter. Has a very defined rockers voice, and changes up songs, like "Chasing Cars" and "Fireflies" to make them better. He is the one to beat....Show more

Lacey...Show more

PAIGE MILES. she just hasn't been singing that well.

...but it WANT it to be Tim Urban....Show more