As a selector,what players would you drop for this weeks preliminary matches ? Why ?

Favorite Answer

Bulldogs - Not sure

Pies - No Change

Cats - Drop Lonergan for Mackie, the fact being i think that Mackie provides more run from half back and he is a better player than Lonergan.

Saints - No Change...Show more

Bulldogs: side selected
B:Harbrow, Lake, Hargrave
HB:Gilbee, Morris, Murphy
C: Griffin, Boyd, Wood
FOL: Hudson, Cross, Picken
HF: Johnson, Hahn, Giansiricusa
F: Hill, Hall, Hooper
INT: Williams, Eagleton, Minson, Grant
EMG: Callan, Ward, Roughead

Pies:
B:Shaw, Presti, Johnson
HB:N.Brown, O'Brien, Maxwell
C: Beams, Ball, Wellingham
FOL: Jolly, Swan, Pendlebury
HF: Sidebottom, Dawes, Didak
F: Thomas, Medhurst, Davis
INT: Toovey, Lockyer, Fraser, D!ck
EMG: L.Brown, Cloke, Anthonty

Cats
B: Milburn, Scarlett, Hunt
HB: Mackie, Taylor, Enright
C: Wojinski, Bartel, Sellwood
FOL: Ottens, Ablett, Ling
HF: Varcoe, Mooney, Chapman
F: Johnson, Podsiadly, Stokes
INT: Rooke, Corey, Blake, Byres
EMG: Hunt, Menzel, Hogan

Saints
B:Gilbert, Dawson, Gwilt
HB:Fisher, Godard, Baker
C: Dal Santo, Hayes, Ray
Foll: Gardner, Montagna, Jones
HF: Geary , Kozi, Patterson
F: Milne, Riewoldt, Schneider
INT: Gram, McQualter, King, McEovy
EMG: Clarke, Armitage, Eddy...Show more

I'd drop Blake from Geelong and try and fit Mackie back in the side, they need to be quick over the ground this week and Mackie will definitely ad some run to the defence of Geelong....Show more

Bulldogs - Drop Hooper (Morris could return)
Magpies- It doesn't really matter who they drop (so much depth)
Cats- Drop Blake, use Hawkins as second ruck-man. Bring in Mackie (They need more runners this week)
Saints - Thinking about dropping Dempster (Baker is more experienced, worried about fitness though)...Show more