play dough in fish tank?

I just bought a big fish tank for my kids. no fishes yet, but soon. The woman at petco said I have to wait for the Ph levels and the fish need stuff to hide in and swim around and under. Well, I was thinking, could I get some clay, or play dough and give it to my kids and let them make something for the tank. would that hurt the fish? It seems like it would be cheaper and more fun for my kids if they could make something. I was reading somewhere that I could use little plastic toys but I want the kids to make something. Use it as a rainy day project.

If I cant use clay or play dough can anyone tell me what I can use so they can make stuff for it?

2011-04-28T14:36:05Z

Oh yeah, we're planning on getting neon tetras (I think that's what they're called)

And its a big 20 gal tank.

catx2011-04-28T14:56:09Z

Favorite Answer

As others have said, clay/playdough is a no go. Plastic toys I wouldn't recommend either, some plastics aren't safe and other toys may have sharp bits or have holes where fish could get stuck. Also, it'll all look pretty nasty when it's got a coating of algae! It's easier to find decor from aquatic stores which is aquarium-safe - although still avoid ones with small holes!

The woman at petco wasn't quite right, it's not pH levels you need to wait for, pH is the least of your worries right now. Read up on the nitrogen cycle, fishkeeping is a bit of a science and Neons are particularly fragile. If you skip the cycle, as soon as they're added they'll keel over from new tank syndrome.

In the grand scheme of things, a 20g isn't the biggest tank in the world! It may seem big for a first tank, and it is a good size for a starter set up. Sit it next to a 55g, or a 75g, or a 100g, it starts to look decidedly cramped, beware of MTS, also known as multiple tank syndrome! It takes over us all.

Corydoras2011-04-28T14:40:42Z

Great tank for neons. 20 gallons is absolutely perfect for a shoal. Black gravel I suggest. Unfortunately, the salts in play-doh will leach out and harm the fish. Clay would soften and become slip, and dissolve into the water. Colored non-dry clay has chemicals in it and the dye can hurt the fish. What you could have them do is draw and color a backdrop to put outside on the back of the tank, or make some clay decorations of their fish to put in front of the tank with the fishs' names carved into them or something. There's plenty of creative things they could do as well, such as theme the tank to a specific area, like the Amazon or other South American theme, where your tetras come from using decorations from the pet shop that are fish-safe.

dallas2011-04-28T14:49:05Z

unlike the clay you see in the fish stores play dough contains some chemicals that will harm your fish
if you plan to buy neon tetras you will be fine if you add water purifier to the water just before you put the fish in (many brands on sale at local fish stores)
simply follow directions on the bottle (aproxamitly 1 cap full per 5 gallon of water is the normal)
float the fish in the baggies they came in your aquarium for at least 1/2 hour add a little water from your tank and allow to float for another 15-20 minutes ( this makes sure that the temperature in the baggie and the tank are the same and that your fish do not go into shock
as for decorations you can find many thiongs that will be good in your tank such as rocks from the local river simply boil for 10 minutes them before you place them in your tank
this will also work for a kids project as they can help find the rocks and decide how to place them in the tank
irecomend that you try to find all types and sizes to build hiding places for your fish and caves for them to swim through

Joseph Lorentzen2011-04-28T14:50:20Z

You might want to try a heat gun and food grade plastic. You won't use the play-dough in the tank, but you could form it into the shape you want the food grade plastic to take. Look on youtube for vacuum forming ideas.

Play-dough is non-toxic to mammals - but the coloring and the salts - bad news for fish.

Now, don't give up. You can make items for you tank that are not as difficult as vacuum forming.

One, got to your local ceramics shop. Look at the ggreen-ware they have. They will instruct you on how to clean it and get it fired. Then you can put food safe glazes on it and fire it one last time.

You'll save nothing doing it this way, but you will have unique pieces.

Cycle your tank properly before introducting the fish. http://www.firsttankguide.net/

Chelsea2011-04-28T14:42:20Z

ABSOLUTELY NOT. Have you ever tasted playdough? Its a salt base. Killing any fish instantly. It also has a flour base. It will coat the fish's gills and they won't be able to get any oxygen should they live through the salt.

Clay would be okay if it was a ceramic clay, glazed and fired. Any other clay is either a plastic chemical base or would make the water cloudy.

Show more answers (3)