Who was a better pitcher? Bill Donovan or Hooks Dauss?

I like to ask these questions to get some good opinions.

Bill Donovan 1898-1918
Hooks Dauss 1912-1926

?2011-11-05T11:33:46Z

Favorite Answer

Bill Donovan

toughguy22011-11-05T11:41:26Z

Bill Donavan

W 186
L 139
ERA: 2.69
SO: 1552

Hooks Dauss

W 223
L 182
ERA: 3.30
SO: 1201

My opinion Wild Bill Donavan by a slight margin