Bill Dahlen, Stan Hack, and Ken Boyer?
Should these guys be Hall of Famers?
Should these guys be Hall of Famers?
Der Kommissar
Favorite Answer
Dahlen for sure. The other two are borderline cases, although Bill James supports Boyer's candidacy, and I don't presume to argue with Bill James.
el Águila
I fully support Bill Dahlen, and honestly think he is the BEST player NOT in the Hall of Fame (and retired before 1955; and isn't Joe Jackson, who isn't eligible anyway).
I'm on the fence with the other two. I like Stan Hack better than Keny Boyer, though.