Should I send my daughter to 1st grade or let her repeat Kindergarten?
My daughters bday is middle of November and I sent her to kindergarten last sept, now school is ending and her teacher is suggesting I let her repeat kindergarten. We have had plenty of meetings and she is thinking she may benefit from it but not 100% saying keep her back. I am so confused because I am not sure if it will hurt her to send her forward or hurt her to keep her back. Academically she is ok, she is not behind but she is alittle immature. I have talked to so many people including her doctor and I am still having a hard time deciding. She does give me a hard time every morning about going and says she wants to stay home with me and her brothers, and says she doesn't like it and does not want to go. Any advice or opinions would be great thank you
Jesus saves2012-06-02T07:32:44Z
Favorite Answer
It is possible,she is having problems with sensory overload,that may be,why she doesn`t want to go to school.May be bothered by flourescent lights,also sensitivity to sounds,crowded school.Look at Irlens Syndrome.Some nutriitonal supplements may help,with anxiety.Essential fatty acids,B-complex 100,a good multi vit and mineral supplement.Also,some good books are Gut and Psychology Syndrome and the LCP Solution.Look at reviws at Amazon.
I think that you should have her repeat kindergarten.
My cousin (she's 12 now and will be in 7th grade) had a similar problem. She understood the material for the most part, but would often fall asleep in class and wasn't as mature. Her parents had her repeat kindergarten and I think it helped.
If your daughter repeats, they'll probably give her a different teacher. This is a plus because she will learn different things (since all teachers teach differently. In kindergarten, you're pretty much friends with everyone. She can keep her friends from this year, but she'll also be able to make new friends.
You don't want her to get into 1st grade and get behind. It can cause trouble in the long run. Maybe watch her over summer and see if she matures. The new school environment might be what makes her act immature. If she seems like she's matured and you think that she's ready, then send her to 1st grade in the fall.
I would send her to first grade. Like you said, academically she is ok. Lots of children in elementary school act immature and develop at different ages. Just because she's a little immature does not mean she will not develop within the next year (maybe later) and get up to the "average" mature. If she's doing fine academically, she will do fine in first grade. She won't be the first, or the last child to be a little immature in first grade. Chances are she will grow out of it.
Also, lots of kids want to stay home with their families. Who knows, she might have a change of heart in first grade. Also, think about this. Say you decide to hold her back, when she's a junior in high school, how do you think she would feel if she COULD have been a senior instead? I would have been so upset if I had to spend an extra year in school!
As a instructor and a mom of an April 5 3 hundred and sixty 5 days outdated, this question has arise in our better 1/2 and youngsters, too. i imagine that is major first to think about in case your daughter is emotionally waiting for kindergarten. It sounds out of your description that she has been very valuable in her Montessori software. She maximum probable has a sense for school room routines and expectations at her grade aspect. despite the indisputable fact that the rush now could be for better teachers on the kindergarten aspect, I have under no circumstances seen a kindergarten classification that does no longer include relaxing and play into their curriculum. At this age aspect, instructors anticipate adulthood ranges to be different. My education experience has targeted on the midsection college aspect. i will allow you to comprehend from seeing 1000's of midsection schoolers that age performs a really small section once you communicate of 'leaders'. human being personality and the arrogance that she builds between her friends and residential over a era of time will be an greater aspect in no matter if she is a 'chief'. If after interpreting your responses, you nevertheless have doubts, i'd make an appointment with the kindergarten instructor on your daughter's skill college. percentage your concerns and that i'm confident that no count number number what your decision, your daughter will be in simple terms tremendous.
Talk about all of this with her teacher. Honestly, when children are in kindergarten, they are fairly much friends with the other children in their class (so it wouldn't be huge for her to "leave her friends" I don't think). In my opinion, There are of course pros and cons to each side. You would not want your child to be bored academically repeating kindergarten, but if you are afraid that she is not mature enough for first grade, repeating kindergarten would be something that could help her.
Is your kindergarten a full day program or half day? (Transitioning from half day to full day when she already has difficulty going to school in the morning could cause more difficulties)
Also, if your school has a multi-age room (kindergarten and first grade in the same classroom together) it might be very helpful for her to have the first grade academics, but the kindergarten social skills reinforced