Supernatural fans: List your favourite seasons from best to worst?

What's your favourite season? What's your least favourite season? List your favourite seasons from best to worst and state your reasons if you wish so.

2012-12-09T09:23:22Z

Season 8 looks to be good since its back to having the Demons as the primary antagonists. I like the new direction.

?2012-12-10T12:32:41Z

Favorite Answer

Season Five: Mainly for Swan Song (best episode of all time) but also because the season was well paced and the episodes were generally very good. Even though I don't like the angels, I really loved the Micheal vs Lucifer storyline

Season One: My babies! Saving people, hunting things, the family business! I miss the days when Sam and Dean really cared about each other and there were no secondary characters in the way.

Season Two: Some of the best episodes, plus it's still very brother-centric

Season Three: The most painful of the seasons, for sure. Bela and Ruby were good, though I do like Ruby 2.0 more.

Season Six: People critique this season a lot, but I LOVED soulless!Sam! He was a fantastic character and I loved getting to see into his head. Though I was VERY upset when Dean didn't kill Castiel for breaking Sam's wall. That was completely OOC.

Season Seven: Castiel being off the show for so long was fantastic, and I loved the fact that Sam got character growth and his own story line. Jared and Mark's acting knocked it out of the park. Plus, I was glad to finally see Bobby go.

Season Four: We get introduced to Castiel and then he doesn't go away. Plus, shitty fillers like Family Remains and Criss Angel is a Douchebag. Those were terrible episodes.

Season Eight: Bad writing, bad characterization, bad storylines, bad bad bad everything

Lynn2012-12-09T08:52:45Z

I really can't choose which of the first 5 seasons are the best. I love them all equally, Eric Kripke is a genius.
Season 6+ are just terrible, not good at all. The thing that bothers me most of season 6+ is the fact that Sam and Dean has done nothing to try to get Adam out of hell.
I miss Supernatural the way it used to be when Eric was running the show. They should have just ended it after season 5.

wanderluster.2012-12-09T16:25:36Z

Season 5 - A strong storyline and it really pulled the brother's together and showed who they deeply are.
Season 3 - Showing just how close the boys were and trying to find their way out of the deal.
Season 2 - This season was really about the family. Who they are, what they'll do for each other, and just how f--ed up they all really are.
Season 1 - Yay! We get to see what's going on and get a horror movie every week.
Season 4 - Now a plot really begins to form with the angels and demons preparing for their showdown.
Season 7 - It had some good elements, but...meh.
Season 6 - WTF WAS WITH SAM LOSING HIS SOUL?!

I'm the Doctor2012-12-12T05:55:28Z

Only seen 1-6 and I like them in that order, 1 being my favourite ( I liked six slightly more than five though), the other seasons had its moments but they kinda screwed it a bit. Still a fan though.

Anonymous2012-12-09T10:16:46Z

S1 - i really really loved it was seeing spn for the very first time
3 deans deal n whether he ll really go to hell

2 the psychics round up n sammy dies but is back brought due to dean
4 sam hits up dean not to my liking
5 bros fight due to lucy
8 yay crowley is back as the bad guy
6 sammy lost his soul
7 not so much

Show more answers (3)