Sizemore or A-Rod?

ALEX RODRIGUEZ of course are you crazy? That's a no brainer

Once agian I am not saying A-Rod is a bad player which is what people are taking this as. Go back 5 years, whos the best player in baseball? A-Rod. Now? Sizemore. Ambrose you forgot out the part where you said Sizemore sucks. Sizemore is not my favorite player and yes I probably am biased here but you could make an argument either way.

well sizemore has tremendous upside...has he performed like everyone has expected him to...nope not this year

Last year Sizemore had like 50 doubles, 25 hrs, 20 Sbs, and 10 triples along with zlmost 200 hits and almost .300 batting average...thats crazzy...he's one of like 5 players EVER in MLB to serve up stats like in all those categories

But I have to take A-Rod's side cuz dude has accomplished SOOOOOOOOO FRICKIN much at such a young age...he's got a long waaaaaaaaay to go and its scary he's only in the middle of his prime.

A rod as accomplished more and put up great numbers consistently year after year...if sizemore does his thing for 5 more years like he did last year, sizemore would have my vote

But for now A-Rod is the best player compared to the two and the best player in the league right now hands down

red4tribe is blinded by loyalty that's all. Nothing he says is based on logic. Most people who are religious about something refuse to see the truth, it doesn't matter if it is right in their face.

To even speak of Sizemore in the same breath as A-Rod is blasphemy.

Alex ROdriguez is Much better

In a few years Grady Sizemore might be one of the best OF's in the league.

Right now A-Rod is Superior

Sizemore is probably his favorite player, there is nothing wrong with loyalty, but AROD is better and everyone knows it. I got Sizemore on my fantasy team and is on pace for 160 strikeouts and has not even ever hit .300 yet, but he definately got skills, I would'nt even put him in the same class as Ichiro.

Is there any doubt? Even though A-rod is one of the biggest pricks in the league, he is a far better player than Sizemore at this time.

Take this year:

A-Rod has the most Hr's and RBi's in the AL, and Sizemore doesn't. Simple as that, so just ignore him if it doesn't work.

Arod a better hitter because he is a home run hitter and hits RBI and has been so good This year and has been amazing the 9th inning

Arod hands down.