Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Is my boyfriend's mother interfering too much?
I feel like my partner's mother is interfering with our relationship. We have been together for about a year and a half and have recently moved across the country together. His mother seemed to be very supportive of this, but for some reason her sincerity never seemed very sincere to me.
My partner is 21 and has lived with either of his parents up until just a few months ago, when we moved in together. Since the beginning, I have sat back and observed the kind of relationship he has with his parents, and it has always seemed to be rather unhealthy to me.
His problems with his father aside, his mother has always been like all other mothers: very protective and extremely overbearing. What makes their relationship especially complicated is that she got cancer 14 years ago and struggles with it to this day. Somehow this seems to complicate things.
I grew up without a mother. She died when I was three, and I was raised by my single, gay father. I have always had a hard time dealing with other women. I do not know how to deal with that overbearing parent I never had.
When we first got together and lived in the same town as our parents, we spent a lot of time at his mother's house. She was completely smitten by me. She would always invite me over and share very private stories and buy me presents. My partner and I got together in September, and by Christmas, she went all out. I was not expecting any of it. It felt nice that we were friends, but as someone who is motherless, I have never had any interest whatsoever in adopting a mother at 21.
That winter, my partner and his mother got into a big fight, and she threw him out and told him to move in with me. This was a problem because I lived with two other girls, and not only was the apartment too small for someone else to move in, but he had no business being there. When I told him this, he said it was no problem and that he would sleep in his car. I gave in. My housemates were extremely upset with me, and my partner and I kept fighting, as my room was very small and he just had to bring all six instruments with him. Even worse, his mother could not understand how I could have been upset with her. She even told my partner that I was ungrateful: that she apparently gave me the best Christmas of my life (even though I never said that).
When their fight was resolved and my him moved back in, everything got back to normal within a few months. But she stopped inviting me over and never let me sleep over, even though she used to encourage it. She blamed the landlady who, admittedly, did not like me.
A couple months before my partner and I moved away together, he temporarily moved to Texas to work for his father so that he could save the money that he needed to start his life on the West Coast. During that time, I moved in with my father so that I could save money. Even though my relationship with my father was great, living with him was quite difficult, as I did not have my own room or even a bed to sleep on. Thus, I ended up spending time with his mother: she was lonely after he left. Suddenly the landlady was perfectly OK with my spending the night.
At first it started with the extremely nice gesture of buying us water-proof winter jackets. When you are new to a rainy city, it is a necessity, and I could not have been happier to accept the gift. Then she sent a few boxes of household items that we did not have. She had told us she planned to even before we left, so it did not feel weird. This past Thanksgiving, our funds were pretty low, so she sent us a Trader Joe's gift card for $100, which helped out a lot and allowed us to make a nice meal for the holiday. But lately it is getting crazy. She is sending us huge boxes full of stuff. Soooo many clothes, we do not know what to do with them all. We have four times as many knives as we do hands. And that $100 gift certificate was the first of many.
I was on the train earlier today and realized that everything I was wearing except my socks and shoes -- jacket, underclothes, pants, shirt, backpack-- were all gifts from her. She has bought our food for the last month. She told my partner the other day that she created an emergency fund for us both incase we cannot make rent. This all from a woman who is on disabilities! Now she is even talking about moving here so that we can live with her!
Perhaps I sound like I am an ungrateful girl. I do not think that I am. I appreciate the clothes and the food and everything else she has done. But I feel like I am becoming dependent on her. My father is an extremely loving parent, but he has always let me make my own mistakes and my own decisions. But my partner has a mother who is encouraging him to mess up so that she might benefit. It would have been one thing for her to create an emergency fund incase we needed to borrow money for rent: it is quite another to offer that when we are doing fine. That is enabling irre
6 Answers
- Anonymous1 decade agoFavorite Answer
I think that she doesn't want to let go of her son. It's hard when a mother's baby moves away, and that's exactly how she feels. What is your partner saying about this? I think that you need to find a way to tell her that she needs to let go, or to hint it to her, but only if it's really bothering you. Assure her that you are doing fine, and although her help is wonderful, you don't want to become dependent on it.
Good Luck.
- 5 years ago
If you are still in high school, and he was doing his homework, please be patient and wait until he is done. You will make much better head wave with his mother if you do so. When you try to but heads by stressing the fact that you are 18 and can do what you want, you are being a little inconsiderate to the fact that in a mother's view, her priority is making sure that her son is successful in school. If you go along with this, you will help him, her, and yourself. When graduation comes, he will have more free time to spend with you without such friction from her.
- SonoranAngelLv 61 decade ago
I'd be careful about allowing her to give so much. It sounds like she may be providing all of this to make you feel indebted to her in case she needs you to help care for her if her health takes a big turn for the worse and she needs taken care of. Guilt trips are used for that also. Then she may feel guilty and try to buy back respect or whatever. You said your BF lived with his parents up until a few months ago. It takes awhile to get used to the idea of parenting differently when the child grows up. It's really hard to say what her motive is, if any. Your BF needs to have a talk with her and tell her that you guys need to try and make it on your own as much as possible and that she can't afford to do what she is doing. Nothing is more complicated than relationships with "in-laws". That's for sure. It does sound like she is trying to be supportive of you guys but it's hard for her. Sometimes trying to do too much seems like interfering. It may be, but I've heard worse horror stories. Good luck and see what you can do to figure out what boundaries you need and communicate them as gently as possible to her.
- 6 years ago
Prob an unpopular opinion but I would give the world to have a mother in law like her having lost my own mother. My partners mother is a vile snob who looks down on me and uses her age as an excuse to make rude, unfounded spiteful remarks about me and to poison him against me. She does not invite me to any family gatherings and as I write this I am contemplating ending my relationship simply because of her and the influence she has over him. Next time I think I will find a bloke without a mother :(
- Anonymous1 decade ago
You are very sharp, first of all. I am only writing to say that no, you are not being unreasonable or ungrateful. You sound very willing to acknowledge that she is helping, but intelligent enough to realize that her slight interference at this stage is unsettling (even if it's in a helpful way on the surface).
I do completely agree that you should be cautious that if she should decide to move to where you are, that will put an inevitable strain on things.
Two things that are very telling of her personality: That she became upset and closed you out after the argument when he moved out, expecting him to move in with you... and secondly, her "I'm in control, so pay me respect" position of telling him that she gave you the best Christmas of your life. Pretty gutsy to say such a thing. Yikes.
Proceed with caution. I know she is doing a lot for you guys, but you need to keep your head on your shoulders (even when your partner isn't) and keep a safe distance (as far as relying on her financially) while maintaining a good relationship with her.
I know I haven't helped much in my answer, but I guess I wanted to say that if you're doubting yourself in any way, you shouldn't be. I completely agree with your hesitation in getting too wrapped up with her. And I would be very nervous if you hear that she is moving out to where you two are.
Good luck with things. And follow your instincts with this situation. I have a strong feeling after reading what you've written, that they will serve you well. :-)