Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

How to convince mother it's time to go into assisted care accommodation?

A friend's mother is getting to a point where she can't properly look after herself but she insists on staying in her own home. Family members want to find her an assisted living place but she is very resistant.

She's had falls, is not taking care of her personal hygiene, gets her medications mixed up and, yet, when she was recently assessed they determined she could stay at home.

Her family is at their wits end. They all have full time jobs and do what they can (taking her to medical appointments etc.) but can't keep rushing out to her at all hours of the day and night to pick her up when she falls or needs other assistance.

They can't understand why she would want to stay in an old house that she can't take care of, where she is lonely and especially as she is often unable to even wash herself properly when they are prepared to find her a modern, purpose-built unit that has onsite medical assistance and where she would meet people and have company etc.

Can someone shed some insight as to why she is so insistent on staying where she is when she would be better off in an aged care facility. If her family could understand her thinking perhaps they could accept her decision or it would help them to reason with her about the move.

Update:

Only one of her children lives in the same city as her but on the other side of town and they have young children. They can’t just leave the children, or take time off work every time she has a fall or needs some other assistance. They regularly take her shopping and to appointments but when they get a call in the middle of the night they can’t just come running.

She has home help for house cleaning but is convinced they are untrustworthy. She has the pharmacy pack up her medications for her but she still mixes them up or doesn't take them. She smells because she soils her pants and doesn't change them for days.

She is housebound because of ill health and doesn’t see anyone for days until her home help arrives. She admits she’s lonely but still she doesn’t want to be where she would meet people and have company. Her family doesn’t understand this and I was hoping you could give me some insight as to why. I wasn’t asking for your ill-informed judgements and recriminations.

Update 2:

She has an emergency alarm and has had to use it several times. On one occasion she fell while cooking dinner. It took over two hours for her child to get away from work, drive from the other side of the city in peak hour traffic and get to her. Meantime the stove was on and her dinner still cooking. Had she been frying something rather than boiling it, she could have burned the house down and died in the fire.

The last time she had to use the emergency call was at 2.00 am when she had again fallen. Even if her family members had been able leave their children and go to her they would not have been able to help her. There’s only two of them and it took four ambos to get her up. Meantime she had been lying helpless on the floor.

Update 3:

Funnily enough, they don't want this kind of life for their mother. They want her in a place where she could “take her stuff”, where someone would come and help her immediately, where her medications would be properly administered, where she would be clean and looked after and would have company and, most of all, where she would be closer to them so they could see her more often and actually visit with her.

How dare you judgemental people assume otherwise!

Would you like your mother to be living like this – in her own home?!

Do you people not get that she is not safe in her own home?

7 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    This is a common problem today. Years ago, women stayed at home to do housework, farmwork, etc, and mom and grandmother, and sometimes elderly sisters and aunts lived together as one family. Now things are different. Each generation has its own house and live apart.

    If their mother truely cannot take care of herself and is a danger to herself, i.e. is she forgetful enough to leave dinner on the stove and burn the house down, along with herself, or would she fall, and lay there sufferig? If so, I would suggest the family take matters into their own hands and have their mother evaluated by a case worker, and if necessary, declared incompetent. This sounds cruel, but sometimes it is necessary for the person's own good, and it is necessary for the family to take charge. To me, this shows love and concern for her, not cruelty.

    Good luck to them!

  • LIPPIE
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    I want you to give up your independence and then ask this same question. Think about this honestly, and what a difference you life would be like if you had to be around people that only wanted your money, and all your processions could be stolen. ( This happens 95 % of the time) The only thing they could do is maybe find someone that could help around the house and give them free room for watching out for her. Not someone that was really young, but someone that was closer to her age that needs some where to live and wants companionship the same as her. Remember that this is the woman that gave them birth, and if they can't help take care of her, then they are sorry people.

  • 1 decade ago

    I hope i can help shed some light to your question.

    I work with nurses on a daily basis and a lot of feed back and info we receive from the nurses is that anyone in general that is forced into assisted care withtout their consent tend to be worse off as they decline as its a sign that their independance is gone.

    You pretty much have to look at it from your own eyes would u like to be forced into care when you dont want to be. Sometimes families do put their elderly relatives into care due to them becoming a burden on them. Before they get moved to assisted care units the elderly person should be fitted / given a panic alarm which connects to a nursing service which is able to be there and help the person concerned. Its a 24 hour service and it can be arranged that a home care nurse does make daily visits to the elderly person and assist them with daily chores like helping clean the home and bathing the person and dispensing medication. There are agencies that do provide this service and depending on what is evaluated they either spend a few hours a day with the person or come around every few days to make sure all is ok.

    Dont force someone into care as many ppl decline and end up passing away due to this. Elderly ppl need to feel like they are taking care of themselves in their own homes. Your friends family obviously hasn't looked into these services as they are readily available and no some you dont pay for however most of these services you do. Your friend needs to look into and speak with these agencies and find the best agency to go with. These are all registered nurses and are capable of taking care of ppl in these situations and do on a daily basis.

    Source(s): Working with nurses every day in health care
  • 1 decade ago

    They see and old house that she can't care for any longer. It may be that she sees the home where she lived happily with her husband. The rooms that were filled with her children's laughter. It's hard to leave that behind when you've lost so much else.

    If she can't care for herself, and there is no other way to get her help the kids may have to apply more pressure to get their mom someplace safe for her. There are a lot of levels of assisted living houses, some that would allow her to have way more privacy and individuality, much like she has at home. But there are other options they could explore for at home help if she feels strongly about staying where she's comfortable for now.

  • Blue
    Lv 6
    1 decade ago

    Yes, I can understand. She is in her own home surrounded by her "stuff." She can do what she wants when she wants. There is no phony caregiver talking to her in baby talk and calling her honey.

    Today's generation is one that moves frequently. They are fine with a change of situation. Our generation valued buying a home and staying put. Once you get to be our age, you don't want to leave that which you worked so hard to obtain. You remember the hours you put into painting the kitchen. How happy you were when you bought a new bedroom suite. And there are the knick knacks you brought back from your vacations that spark warm memories. But I'm supposed to give all that up because you can't help me?

    Why don't they look into home health care since none of them seem to want to take the time away from their busy lives to take care of her.

    Their mother and they want to put her away.

  • Put yourself in her shoes would you like it? that house is where her memories are. being a mum herself she was the linch pin of her family , she raised her children put food on their tables, nursed them ,taught them right from wrong stood by them through thick and thin, next thing she knows they want to pack her off, cos she s a burden? sorry but what a **** world. They have full time jobs so did she, being a mum a wife a nan all of her adulthood. sorry but i think family values, morals are missing here. in this day and age she could have some kind of home help ? God help us all cos time waits for no one,it comes to us all OLD AGE.

  • 1 decade ago

    My personal guess would be that she is afraid that you want to just rid of her. Maybe she fears that she will be neglected and forgotten about, and that her family wants to just put her somewhere and forget about her.

    Obviously that is never the case, but that dosent mean that she thinks the same as you. At other times people who are getting older are afraid to admit that they are aged and don't want to appear weak.

    Good luck,

    Sergey

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.