Most Overrated player by position?

Nice Q, Im expecting Gidley to be in the list of some silly people but thats okay, they can just stay jealous the bionic hero isn't in their team lol.

Fullback

1. Nathan Merritt

2. William Zillman

3. Darius Boyd

Winger

1. Steve Turner

2. David Williams

Theres crap wingers but noone who is really overrated

Centre

1. Jordan Atkins

2. Jamal Idris

3. Chris Lawrence

5/8

1. Benji Marshall

2. Ben Roberts

3. Jamie Soward

Halfback

1. Peter Wallace

2. Matt Orford (really sorry lol)

Prop

1. Frank-Paul Nuuausala

2. Bryce Gibbs

3. James Tamou

Hooker

1. Nathan Fien

2. Issac Luke

3. Michael Ennis

2nd Rower

1. Ben Matulino

2. Andrew Ryan (after winning captain of the year)

3. Anthony Laffranchi

Lock

1. David Stagg

2. David Faalogo

3. Neville Costigan

Just my opinions, not so much who I think are bad players just who I dont think lives up to their given reputation.

Since Im the first, hope I dont see offended users putting 20 Knights' players in lol That'd be SLACK

Fullback

1. Darius Boyd - doesn't do special things these days

2. Jarrod Sammut - can't catch for sh!t

3. Wade McKinnon - doesn't do anything nowadays

Winger

1. Sam Perrett - does nothing

2. Shawn Kenny-Dowall - does nothing. Both of them were rated pretty high last year.

3. Jordan Atkins - deemed as something special after 4 tries on debut, he fell away rapidly and is now not a regular of the starting 17. Oh yeah, and ""Big Dell"" is also kinda overrated.

Centre

1. Justin Hodges - he has his off weeks

2. Steve Matai - injuries don't help

3. Sam Tagataese - deemed as a finals weapon he goes along and turns up average games.

5/8

1. Braith Anasta - does nothing

2. Terry Campese - massively overrated it's not funny

3. Jamie Soward - a choke, a choke oh YEAH

Halfback

1. Jarrod Sammut again - remember Sammut the halfback?

2. Mitchell Pearce - doesn't do anything

3. Peter Wallace - off days, 'nuff said

Prop

1. Mark O' Meley - not an ogre, he's the tooth fairy

2. Willie Mason (when he was a prop) - don't need justification here

3. Brent Kite - a shadow of his former self

Hooker

1. Michael Ennis - a thug

2. Cameron Smith - defensive rock, or is he? Not many one on ones.

3. James Aubusson - does ABSOLUTELY NOTHING

2nd Rower

1. Willie Mason - no need for justification

2. Ashton Sims - used to be better, now he's so bad it's not funny

3. Anthony Tupou - $400000?? He's gotta be joking.

Lock

1. Paul Gallen - his brain snaps are NOT funny

2. Craig Fitzgibbon - not as good as everyone thinks

3. Dallas Johnson - all he does is tackle

Fullback

1. Gidley

2. McKinnon- him playing fullback got the Warriors kicked out of the finals. Hohaia was playing so well.

3. Sammut

Winger

1. Wolfman Williams

2. Monaghan

3. Turner

Centre

1. Hodges

2. Matai

3. Tonga

5/8

1. Soward

2. Roberts

3. Campese

Halfback

1. Mullen

2. Robson (if that's possible)

3. Wallace

Prop

1. Hannant

2. Gibbs

3. Civoniceva

Hooker

1. Ennis

2. De Gois

3. Aiton

2nd Rower

1. Bronson Harrison

2. Hoffman

3. Manu

Lock

1. Gallen

2. Gallen

3. Gallen

I was struggling abit towards the end. Obviously, nobody is going to be making many "friends" through their opinions. I know I sure won't be pleasing to many people...

Like Knights 10 said, this is our OPINION, not "what is right", and we are all entitled to our own opinion (referring to the trolls when saying this).

Fullback

1. Stapleton

2. Merritt

3. Milne

Winger

1. Ferguson

2. Mead

3. Locke

Centre

1. Idris (worst player ever)

2. Matai (sorry but this guy is a faking girl)

3. Chambers

5/8

1. Soward

2. Marshall

3. Rovelli

Halfback

1. Wallace (how that guy played origin i will never know)

2. T Carney (can't believe they letting that scum back to ruin our game)

3. Porter

Prop

1. Kite (sorry again, just being honest)

2. M Scott

3. Hickey

Hooker

1. Ennis (my god he is up himself, but he sucks)

2. Watts

3. J Friend

2nd Rower

1. Laffranchi

2. Learoyd Lars (not THE worst player but soooo lazy and over rated)

3. Heighington (used to be the man, pathetic now)

Lock

1. J Smith (future NZ captain my asssss)

2. Costigan

3. Pritchard

Fullback

1.Gidley

2.Darrius Boyde

3.Wade Mckinnon

Winger

1.Wolfman

2.Jordan Atkins

3.Big Dell

Centre

1.Tonga

2.Sam Taga

3.Jamal Idris

5/8

1.Anasta

2.Soward

3.Marshall

Halfback

1.Mullen

2.Mitchell Pearce

3.

Prop

1.Gibs

2.O'Meley

3.Mason

Hooker

1.De Gois

2.Ennis....I hate this fella anyway!

3.

2nd Rower

1.

2.

3.

Lock

1.Gallen

2.David Faalogo

3.Costigan....used to be good.