Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
I would like some constructive criticism on the beginning of my fantasy novel?
The night was beautiful and cloudless. A gentle whisper of a wind tugged at the curtains in Felicity’s bedroom, beckoning her outside. Still in her wrinkly blue chemise with the lace sleeves, she looked like a ghost. Her soft chestnut hair tied in braids, her skinny legs clad in stockings… it was not an outfit suitable to be outdoors in. Nonetheless, she felt an urgent need to leave the imprisonment her bedchamber provided.
Slipping on a pair of ratty black boots and not bothering to tie the laces, the young woman stepped under the doorframe into the dusty kitchen, where all sorts of pots and pans hung across the ceiling. Weaving in and out of their metallic maze, she found herself at the front door. It was a huge, tall, wide door…one that you had to really yank at to open. So after much tugging, moonlight finally seeped through to alight on her pleased face. It picked out the glinting hazel in her big, doe-like eyes.
“Ah, such a gorgeous night!” she cried aloud. However, no one heard but the stars.
Indeed, the garden appeared truly magical tonight. Everything was set with the silvery cloak of twilight, for it was still early evening yet. Tulips and marigolds, with their charming bulbs of prismatic colors, nodded in the soft breeze that issued through the flower patch. The giant weeping willow, its tendrils already caught together with pearly dew, bowed sadly at Felicity.
Daintily, she picked her way down the sandstone walk to the tiny bench by the gurgling fountain. The fountain and the bench both sat in the very middle of the garden in a circle of paved, honey-hued sandstone. As Felicity alighted on the bench and smoothed her crimped underwear, the marble fountain bubbled a hello.
“Yes…hello…fountain…” she whispered forlornly. Yet the fountain could only gush and murmur with its rippling waters.
Felicity stared into the sky, which shone bright with millions of stars. A fat moon smirked down at the earth, his crater-eyes wide and gaping.
At that peaceful, lonely moment, the last thing Felicity expected was to feel a cold hand touch her shoulder….
“Goodness!” her hand flew to her breast. Her heart beat like a drum. “Who’s there?”
She had shot off the bench like a firecracker. Yet as she surveyed the silvery garden, all she saw were shadows and flowers.
“Who’s there?” she repeated, this time with a note of irritation in her shrill voice.
Her shoulder still felt bitterly cold, as if the hand had forever left its mark. Slowly, she reached up to place her fingers there.
“Felicity…is that not your name?”
She leapt around like a startled cat. Drops of sweat dotted her brow. Her limbs were speckled in goose bumps. The hair on the back of her neck stood on end. All around, the rainbow flowers bobbed in the wind and the man in the moon leered from the inky heavens.
It began quite gradually. A magenta dust fluttered from the sky before her eyes. She vaguely felt her hand reach up to grasp it. Yet she could not. The drifty magenta powder slipped away. Darting closer, she strained her eyes to find it once more. The way it sparkled like polished tin captivated her. Never before had she seen something so beautiful.
“Wait!” she cried. “Do not leave! I need you!”
But this was silly. This magical dust was surely inanimate. It did not live. It did not breathe. And yet she yearned for it like a lover would her sweetheart. Her heart tugged her forward. Her muddy hazel eyes glimmered with the dazed look of one lost in thought. Frantic thoughts scurried through her head like stumbling doves.
Felicity had never felt more awake. This was no ordinary night. This was her opportunity, her chance to seek companionship. Most prominent, for at least half of her twenty years, was her desire for a friend…just one loyal, friendly companion. And for some reason, she knew this peculiar rose dust would lead her to her wishes.
Not a moment was to be spared.
As it was, Felicity pursued the glossy rose dust out the garden gate into the cobble street. It was there that a rickety ebony cart was just rattling around the corner, and thereupon the coachman glimpsed a brown-haired young lady in her blue underwear…chasing something with outstretched arms and a crazed face.
Thank you, everyone. I really appreciate your liking it. But if there's anything at all that I could improve on... don't hesitate to say. =)
@ qт... ιѕ α gℓєєк™
Yes! It takes place in a completely fictional place in the 1860's.
Ms. Search and Destroy: Thank you! I will definitely revise some of the more overdone, "purple prose" sentences. You give wonderful advice. =)
11 Answers
- 1 decade agoFavorite Answer
Pretty good.
Seems to me that this is "purple prose", though not incredibly bad. Just in that you use a lot of adjectives and adverbs. Adjectives are, obviously, important but using them in excess is bad technique. This is even more true of adverbs. As a rule, many writers often say that if the verb itself can't get across what you are trying to show, without the aid of adjectives, then the verb itself isn't strong enough.
For instance, "Daintily" in the fifth paragraph is not necessary. In fact, it disrupts the flow of that sentence. The description afterwards does a fine job of giving the correct image. Now to focus on the first paragraph: The first few sentences flow nicely, though I would say "wind" instead of "a wind". Not sure if the outfit itself makes her look like a ghost, though I see what you mean. Maybe focus on the paleness of her skin? I would use a -- instead of ... (pardon me for forgetting the terms) afterwards. I would use ... very sparingly, and even then usually in dialogue. The last bit of the last sentence seems a little awkward. "The imprisonment of her bedchamber" would work better.
Jumping down to the bit about the fountain, I would say "forlornly" still disrupts the flow. Is there some way you could describe her that would suggest how sad she seems? Her eyes perhaps? And in "The drifty magenta powder", it again seems like too much description. "Drifty" doesn't add much to the image, thus can be taken away (and I'm not even sure if that is a word). And there are certainly more places I would look out for.
So what I mean to say, I suppose, is just to be careful with your descriptions. Don't get too held up in how elaborate it has to be, because with too many descriptions/adjectives/adverbs, it can disrupt the flow of your writing.
Of course, overall it is still very good; it's just a matter of being careful and looking back to catch yourself. I suggest looking at novels similar to yours, or those that you enjoyed, and looked how they pace their adjectives and adverbs. How do they achieve the flow of their writing? (And by the way, concerning the actual plot progression so far, very good! You're slowly building up tension, making me ask questions; certainly one of the best materials I've ever read!)
Keep it up ;)
- ?Lv 45 years ago
I agree with your other poster about the repetition. Your writing style is very readable though I would hope for lighter moments later in the narrative. The horrendous apostrophe: A pain in the whatnot but truly necessary to the language. It is usually a shortening in some way in recompense for a missing letter ( It's =It is) or to save using extra letters or words (Boss' posessive. Bosses multiple). Hope this helps.
- MJLv 61 decade ago
Very good. It's really interesting, but I feel like you're putting in "big words" just for the sake of having high-level vocabulary. Nothing wrong with that, I guess. Just an observation. :) Just don't try to mimic other writers' styles.
Also, does this take place in the past? I don't know any young adult who talks like that, haha. So I'm guessing it's in a more conservative time period/location?
- 1 decade ago
Wow! That is great! Keep writing, it was just..out of my mind! I couldn't stop reading, until the end, and like someone else said, i did shout in frustration. You're a really good writer. Keep it up!
- 1 decade ago
Dear god that was amazing. I couldn't stop reading to save my life and when I finally came to the end I quite literally shouted in frustration. Keep writing, your amazing and most definitely have a gift.
- 1 decade ago
That was very good!
I honestly cannot find anything to complain about.
So you get my first 5/5 rating! :)
- Anonymous1 decade ago
I cannot wait to read the published book. :)
Best of luck to you, though I do not think you will need it. Intriguing, and your writing is simply stunning.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
Oh goodness! I love that! So creative and original, what's the dust? What's going to happen next? i hope you write more!
- 1 decade ago
i really like this; you paint a good picture in my mind. very good imagery. you show rather than tell which i always commend. carry on!
- 1 decade ago
Oh goodness! I love that! So creative and original, what's the dust? What's going to happen next? i hope you write more!