why is every body so high on colts manning?

I know right? Brady is the man:) 3 rings! at the end of the day it's about winning Super Bowls not throwing 5,000 yards.

Where do you weenies come up with the idea that a team's success determines the ability of an individual player? There's 21 other players on the field. No one man can win a Super Bowl. How many tackles did Brady make in the Pats three Super Bpwl wins? By your reasoning, Jeff Hostetler and Jim MacMahon were better quarterbacks than Jim Kelly. That's retard logic.

Peyton Manning is consistent. That is what you want in a quarterback. Brady has more rings basically because of a better defense. Manning would flourish if he played on those Patriot teams, so would Big Ben or Favre. Manning gets the best out of what he's got to work with.

Tom brady is good, but completely overrated.

Whereas Peyton Manning is a robot sent from the future to reshape the face of football as we know it.

what does there past record or the patriots past record have to do with this year. Colts would kill patriots

better question is he going to play this weekend for all 4 quarters?

Three words... FOURTEEN AND OH!