What about Michaela Sophie?

Michaela Sophie is a gorgeous name, and I love the nickname "Kaylie" for her! :)

Out of your list, I think that Michaela and Madeline go well together... (I also love the spelling "Madelyn") I also like Michaela and Charlotte.

Here are a few other suggestions:

Jewell

Audrey

Jasmine

Claire

Melanie

Mackenzie

Katherine

Riley

Kylie

Liesel

Chloe

Leia

Payson

Devon

Charlotte

Good Luck :D

Michaela is a beautiful name i personally think, its just sounds so classy. There are many nicknames for this name. There could be Miki, Kayla, Kay, Kaylie or even Em (M). Michaela and Charlotte i think don't pair up, same goes with Annabelle and Cassandra as well as Cassidy (although i like those names). Madeline would go great with Michaela, and i would spell Madeline, Madeleine it just looks more unique and would be gorgeous to write out in a script type of font. Other names that would go great with Michaela could be Michelle, Savannah, Tori, Amelia. For the middle name Sophie i am not fond of it at all. Michaela Sophie just doesn't go. Michaela Rose, Michaela Grace, Michaela Cassidy would also look great.

I Hope I Helped

I love Michaela Sophie!!! :) So super cute!

I also like Michaela Cassidy from your list of names

I babysit for a girl whose name is spelt just like yours and we always call her Michaela never Michael or have I ever heard of anything stupid like that. I also have a cousin who has her name spelt Mikayla, maybe a better spelling for a Kayla nickname?

No suggestions on other middle names because I really, really love your Michaela Sophie combo.

It's prettier switched around

Sophie Michaela

Michaela is the female form of Michael and I would have to agree that her nickname would be something more masculine like Mike ,Mikey or Mic. No one ( but you) would think of calling her Kayla.

Michael is commonly used as a middle name for men as well.

Charlotte Michaela is nice is really nice too.

I really like Michaela Sophie :) it's super cute!!

my best friends name is Michaela and she is always gettin crap for it!!! People constantly call her Michael and laugh..... and no shes not 7 were 13 (yep alot of people 2day are that immature!)