Hermione vs. Katniss vs. Annabeth?

That's not fair. If Hermione can't have a wand, and Annabeth can't have her hat or knife, then Katniss can't have a bow and arrows. Now it's fair.

Also, I'm assuming they're all the same age in this. Let's say 17, 'cause that's when they pretty much have their greatest achievements.

I think Annabeth is more likely to win. She's fought a lot more people and monsters than Katniss. Hermione's never tried to fight without a wand, I don't think. Unless, I've missed something.

Annabeth could still fight without any weapons, however, taking away Hermione's wand, one would logically have to take away Annabeths mother and demigod powers. The only reason Annabeth is smart, wise, or brave or possibly even pretty is because of her mother. She would be nothing without Athena. Hermione is genuinely smart, she worked for it. Plus, she is much more realistic and has been through a lot more than Annabeth.

Katniss though, in the end, would be the most likely to win. Annabeth would be the first to go out of the three. Hermione might stand a chance in physical fighting, she went through the battle of Hogwarts after all.

It comes down to hermione and katniss.

I say katniss, but only if she had her bow.

Annabeth.

Even if her weapon and her magic hat is taken from her, she can still get a sword/knife once she is in the arena and she has been trained since she was 7 years old to use a weapon. She is extremely smart and she can think up a plan within seconds while Hermione is useless without her wand, she will just be like a normally person and I don't think she could stand the idea of stabbing someone while Annabeth and Katniss have both shown they can. Annnabeth with Luke and Katniss has killed before.

Katniss has got through two games before but that was because she hid away in book one with Peeta and just let the others kill themselves and in book 2 nobody was trying to kill her as they all were working together apart from a few and they got killed. Annabeth could make a plan to stay out of the way or to kill and like Katniss, Annabeth can climb very well from the training she's had from Chiron and she is smart to form an alliance with Katniss but then she may let Katniss have an 'accedent' or something, but that's not really in Annabeth's style

Well, if Hermione has no wand she is powerless, shes dead.

Annabeth really has no power except battle strategy. And she is pretty good with a sword.

Katniss is really good with a bow. She could kill of Hermione no problem. But Katniss and Annabeth will have a dual. I think Katniss would win because she is very very good with a bow. :)

I would say Katniss would win the Games as I don't think Hermione or Annabeth have the survival skills and would probably starve to death without help from Sponsers or food provided by the Gamemasters.

Annabeth as she is a daughter if Athena and she always has a plan, so while Hermione is bright Annabeth is smarter as she mother is the goddess of wisdom and while Katniss will have Peeta looking out for her Annabeth could over power them both.

I don't like this question as it means Annabeth will kill Peeta :'( You're a meanie! (joke)

Annabeth. Hermione would die for sure without her wand, and Katniss had Peeta to protect her in the first and everyone else in the second.

wow thats hard because they are some of all time favorite characters. i hate to say it but katniss because annabeth would be oit pretty quick and hermione while good with her brain and wand isnt as physically fit or prepared.

Hermione! She older, wiser, logical, plans ahead and can always come up with a solution.

I know Annabeth is just about the same but I think if put on the spot Hermione would be able to ignore the pressure and have something in a second. Annabeth is more tough/fighter I think she'd spaz and try to just fight plus she has the whole ADHD thing so it would be harder for her to focus in the moment

HERMIONE

I have to say Katniss, since survial is her field. While Annabeth may have a chance with her quest experience, Katniss would still win because she has hunting and forging experience.