Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Balto asked in TravelItalyPerugia · 10 years ago

Should they remake the movie about Foxy Knoxy?

Hayden Panettiere Made a movie about Amanda Knox and her trial for the murder of Meredith Kercher for the Lifetime TV cable channel.

This movie was a failure because of defects in the plot. They went to Perugia to film some exterior shots, and did the court scene inside an actual Italian courtroom, and the people who made this movie put in the work, but the writer who wrote the screenplay did a bad job.

I think this would have been a good movie if they had told both sides of the story, as well as the 3rd side, i.e. combine 3 different versions of what happened.

This would have been a good opportunity for Hayden Panettiere to show America what a talented actress she is. She could have played 3 versions of her character in 3 versions of the story

1) Amanda the innocent young girl. This part would be based on Amanda's story.

Hayden could make her a child-like naive teenager. She spends the night of Nov. 1 at her boyfriend's place. She does not know of the murder until the next morning, and never understands why anyone would suspect she killed Meredith.

2) Amanda the Satanic priestess. This is based on prosecutore Mignini's 1st theory.

Her boss, Patrick Lumborghina, Meredith, Amanda and her boyfriend get together in Meredith's room. Patrick is a senior member of the Satanic cult, he is doing an initiation ceremony for the other 3. Patrick ties Their hands with zip ties, which are attached to their ankles. They then draw straws, with their mouths from a cup Patrick is holding. Meredith draws the short straw so she is the one the other 2 will sacrifice. Patrick cuts the zip ties on Amanda and her boyfriend. Rafaele holds Meredith while Amanda cuts her.

3) Amanda the seductress. This is based on Mignini's 2nd theory.

Amanda comes home and finds Rudy and Meredith there together. She has her boyfriend with her. She suggests that all 4 of them do this sex game. The 2 guys get turned on and they are really keen on doing the 4 way. Meredith refuses, Amanda says "don't be a party pooper". Meredith calls Amanda a whore and a bunch of things that are unmentionable. Amanda gets mad and stabs her. Rudy ****s the corpse, Her boyfriend lost his erection, so they leave.

The audience is shown all 3, and they can make up their own minds as to which one they will believe.

3 Answers

Relevance
  • 10 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    C'mon Panetteire can't act well, she is a whore who gets parts by sleeping with the producer

  • Anonymous
    10 years ago

    This movie is a work of fiction. The screen play was written by people who belong to a group called the guilters.

    According to the guilters Amanda is guilty and the cops knew she was, shortly after they began their investigation, because it was so obvious she was.

    While Lifetime claims that this is a true story, the guilters who wrote it included 5 things that are false that make it appear that there is evidence to prove Amanda was involved.

    The producers were allowed to film in an Italian court room and to film in Perugia. In order to get Italy to do them a favor, the producers must have made some kind of deal with the Italian government where they help with the production if the producers include some suggestions that Amanda is guilty.

  • 10 years ago

    It seems obvious to me, that the judge and jury must have heard what the police found out when the hid a wire tap and bug inside Rafaeles apartment.

    They keep this secret, so the prosecutor thought up that ridicuolus story and they acted out a performance to make people think they proved Knox's guilt using legal methods.

    They knew Amanda and Rafaele were guilty from the things this couple said when they were talking about Meredith.

    It is a well guarded secret that the Italian police use this method, therefore the prosecutor can't play the recording he heard in court, even though the recording is what convinced him that Rafaele and Amanda are guilty.

    So the real story is Amanda is acting innocent and Prosecutore Mignini knows she is guilty, as do the Judges and Jury.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.