Two different girls like me. What do I do?

So almost exactly one year ago I told my close friend that I liked her. We never really got anywhere and slightly stopped talking. We've been talking a little more recently, and today she told me she liked me and another guy, my friend auctally. She also randomly said it would be nice if someone got asked out on new years. I haven't lost my feelings for her, in fact I still like her a lot. The problem is... Another girl. I've been talking to her recently a little more that the first girl. I know she's liked me for a while and she knows I like her a little. The thing is... I always text her and rarely ever see her her. But with the first girl, I see her at least once a week. When I text her we have a lot more to talk about because our families are a lot closer. So which girl is it? Girl one or girl two? Please help me