Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Dead 2007 Mini Cooper S, Advice?
I bought a 2007 Mini Cooper, used, at a Ford dealership in August of 2010. For nearly two years I loved this car and didn't have to pay much in the way of maintenance. I bought the car at 55k miles, and now it has 92k. Over the past year, I have noticed a rattling noise at cold startup, and it was especially loud in the winter, and I also noticed that the car consumes oil. As the oil got lower, the rattling got worse, and whenever I topped off the oil the rattling stopped. I brought this up at the MINI dealership (where I get all my repairs on the car) during a routine oil change and they didn't take it seriously.
Well, Tuesday morning on my way to work, there was a sudden loss of power and the engine started missing bad. I was almost to where I work when the car just couldn't hold and idle and stalled. It wouldn't turn over after that and it sounded really "sick". I had the car towed to the dealer, where they told me the timing chain tensioner failed and it allowed the timing belt to jump "a great distance". Apparently, these are "interference" engines (a term I learned because of this incident) so the screwed up timing destroyed the engine. The dealer said it will cost 8,000 to completely replace the engine.
I told them to hold on to it while I figure things out, as I cannot slap that money down. Since then, research has shown this has happened to others. I got in contact with one of them who is still in the process of a lawsuit with MINI USA since late 2010.
http://www.northamericanmotoring.com/forums/stock-...
I have heard many different explanations for the rattling, something that has been well documented, but it's hard to believe that the rattling, the oil consumption, and my car self-destructing is unrelated. Mini apparently issued a "service bulletin" to correct the rattling but it didn't solve anything, and I do not know if it has been applied to my car by the previous owner.
http://www.motoringfile.com/2008/02/20/r56-mcs-eng...
Further research on these forums states that the rattling is absolutely to due with the timing chain tensioner not getting enough oil on cold starts.
http://www.northamericanmotoring.com/forums/stock-...
http://www.northamericanmotoring.com/forums/stock-...
So far I am still trying to figure out my options of resolving the issue. I still owe quite a bit on the car, more than it was worth before the engine self-destructed, and don't have the money to pay for these repairs. I have contacted my USAA insurance on the hopes they can help pay for it, other than that my only option seems to be to take out a loan, or raise a stink about it with the dealer, which I'm pessimistic on considering what I've heard from others with the same issue.
Do you have any advice or ideas on how I can resolve the issue?
3 Answers
- mongojustapawnLv 49 years agoFavorite Answer
First shop around. 8K is a lot for an engine replacement. Someone out there can do if for half that to include cost of engine. You may have to settle for a used engine, but if the engine you get has less then 94K on it, you will be doing good. The dealers are the worse for price. There are a lot of good mechanics out there, you just have to find the right one. Ask around and find a reliable one. USAA may be able to give you a reference on one. People are under the misunderstanding the cars are an investment, no they are not! You loose money the minute you drive them off the lot. Very few cars appreciate over time. Ask yourself, the purpose of your car? Its a simple question yet few do not realize what a car is for. Here is the answer, ready? It is to get you where you need to go. Its not a statement, its not to race, its not show people you are someone. OK, I will give you that it helps with women, but then again we do so many stupid things to get women. Anyhow, you will have to take a serious hit on the car. Get it fix'd and keep it until you have it paid off. Forget getting the cost of the engine back. That money is gone. You can get another car and have the cost rolled into the new car, but you will have grand kids before that happens. It is a financial hit you have to take. OK, Shop around, get it fix'd and take better care of your car. Yeah, its good to see if mini is defective and owes you anything, but again.............