Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Prong collar for puppy?
When can one begin using a prong collar safely with a puppy of a small yet hardy/muscular breed (such as pit bull)?
Last I checked, prong collars were training tools. You should consider that not every dog owner on the planet will train their dogs the same way you do, now bite your tongue.
Candy floss, prong collars are not meant to be "cruel". When they are used properly, they aren't supposed to hurt the dog at all, just regulate pressure on the neck. They help with stronger dogs that tend to pull, especially those that are handled by smaller/weaker owners.
Lots of negative assuming going on here, isn't that nice... I am educated on how one works, and how to work with it safely. I have seen them used very successfully as temporary methods of teaching dogs, of various breeds, to walk without pulling.
Yes, the particular puppy I am dealing with is one I would consider particularly muscular, and thus, quite strong. He's a about 6 months, and beginning to physically over-power me when he gets over-excited during walks. He is also not my dog, and I am only to walk him with another dog simultaneously when I do take him out. This means there is never an opportunity to give him my full attention, and I pretty much have to make do with what I have. I never said anything about believing it was necessary to use a prong, but I am certain one would help me control his lunging, get his attention, AND in turn, make good walking habits easier to fall into. Sometimes asking on yahoo is helpful with personal experiences, other times not, it was a
oops got cut off that time. Just meant to say thanks for those that offered help! Really appreciate it.
I tried it out today with sweet results for both me and the little guy :)
13 Answers
- 9 years agoFavorite Answer
You would prefer to put a prong collar on a pup rather than train the pup? I don't know as I have never used one. I train my dogs.
- Anonymous5 years ago
you need to hunt down a distinct classification, a coach that does a one length suits all is both not very well experienced or knowledgeable. Prongs are literally not risky if equipped actual and used properly which i imagine a coach ought to artwork with an proprietor on the thanks to apply one, there develop right into a study in germany prong collars led to a lot less injuries than the classic chokes. also the mushy leaders (halits) can damage a dogs if not used actual. I do imagine your dogs is too youthful to apply a prong.
- Anonymous5 years ago
Training your dog will be a huge part of your interaction with him for the first few months. Learn here https://tr.im/ChLPh
This includes housetraining, leash training, obedience training, socialization, and problem solving. In addition to providing your dog with needed skills, this time will also be a great opportunity for you to bond with him. Take the time to really get to know your pet while training him and a loving relationship will easily develop.
- Anonymous9 years ago
Ignore all the bunny huggers who have never actually trained a dog but claim they did. Prongs collars can be safely used on a dog the age of yours, as long as you know what you are doing.
I have used them for 33 years and I have never had a negative incident. As long as you know what you are doing and you make the dog wear it correctly, it will be fine. Hope I helped.
Source(s): Realist - Anonymous9 years ago
Prong collars can be used on Puppies my GSD was trained with one from the age of 4 months he was an Army dog .
You will get different opinions on a lot of things on here but the one person that could answer your question properly has not answered this yet
- jtexasLv 79 years ago
The dog you described, can wear a prong collar now.
My pup, now 11 months and 85 lbs, was 76 lbs at six months when I started using it. I only put it on him now when one of the kids is in charge of the leash, cause he can slip his flat collar if you aren't careful when he gets excited.
If we could all be professional trainers, there would be nobody left to hire a professional trainer.
- MarianneLv 79 years ago
I've been training for competition obedience for over 40 years, and I've seen it all. The whole idea of using a prong collar is to make your dog uncomfortable enough to pay attention to you and anyone that says differently is really not aware of the purpose of using a Prong. No matter how you use it, it will be uncomfortable for your dog if not downright harmful.
A dog trainer that has to resort to using discomfort to train a dog hasn't done their homework on training. There is always a way to train a dog with positive methods without having to resort to "pain", although it gets a quick response, it doesn't do anything for your relationship with your dog.
I've worked with many older dog owners that owned strong dogs that pulled, but never had to resort to a Prong or an electric collar to show the owner how to control their dog. If you understand how your individual dog thinks, and what they like best in the whole world, you can use that to effectively train and control your dog without resorting to the bully method of training.
- 9 years ago
If the dog is trained correctly from the get go and is properly tempered, there is NO reason that you small or weak owner would need a prong collar. The dog needs leash training and good recall.
Personally, I wouldn't touch a prong collar to a dog until the dog is 12-24 months old. Some breeds should NEVER have a prong. Some dogs never should have prongs.
Yes, they are great training tools when proper training has failed and when they are in the right hands. My 80lb German Shepherd puppy was never taught proper leash skills, so he's learning them now via good training, not by a prong collar, a choke chain, or a shock collar.
Edit: Ok, the dog isn't yours. Sorry we didn't read your mind on that.
So, if you can't control him, then you stop walking him. If you can't offer him full attention to train him properly, then you stop walking him.
Tell the owners that the dog is out of control on the leash and that you can't walk him until they've been able to work with him on leash manners.
- ?Lv 69 years ago
I have seen pups as young as 4 months old,however that was with someone who knew how to properly fit it and use it.Prongs are a very good training tool when put in the proper hands.Good luck and best wishes.
Below is a very helpful and useful site on how to fit a prong collar,along with many other prong related topics and Q's.
Source(s): My dog loves her prong. - laughingLv 69 years ago
Prong collars should not be used on puppies.
Also, many dogs can be trained properly without one. A "pit bull" isn't a guarantee that you will have to use a prong. It varies by dog as prongs vary by usage.
As well, if you are going to use a prong, do not come here on Y!A. Go work with a trainer. When a prong is not assembled correctly or used in the proper manner they are dangerous to the owner and dog. Wouldn't you like your "muscular pit bull" running free when the prong falls apart because you didn't assemble it properly? Or you put it on wrong and the dog now has puncture wounds through the neck?
No doubt prong collars are a very useful tool, just get knowledgeable help, and do NOT use for a puppy.