Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Writing Exercise. What do you think?

This is just a little writing exercise from today, and I'm interested to see what people think. Do you like it or not, what parts seem weird or sound awkward, or what parts are interesting or intriguing. I'm trying to learn how to judge my own writing's weaknesses and strengths, and any opinions would be welcome! Thanks B&A!

-------

Our house is old. Not fun old or vintage old. It’s f*cking old. Falling apart, smelly and it’s all we can afford. The only person I can invite over without being embarrassed is Jill, because she lives in a trailer with her grandma and really can’t judge me.

Today, Jill and I were going to sit out in the sun and read magazines in our bathing suits. Of course, it started pouring rain and hasn’t stopped for three hours and the power’s gone out. We stare out my bedroom window like those kids from Cat in the Hat, making clouds on the glass with our breath and drawing hearts and flowers with our fingers.

“Do you still have that Mall Madness game?” Jill asks.

“Mall Madness? What are you, twelve years old?”

“Come on Alisha. My grandma’s not picking me up for another hour and a half and I’m bored!”

I hate that. I don’t want to be The Boring Friend. Even though I’m pretty sure Mom sold Mall Madness at a garage sale, I stand up, stretch my back, grab the cinnamon apple candle from Bath & Body Works and lead the way to the attic.

Technically, I’m not supposed to go up into the attic, ever since that one day when I misstepped and plunged my foot through the insulation in Mom and Dad’s bathroom ceiling. But I was clumsy back then, and I’m not as scared of their threats to ground me as I used to be.

Jill’s asthma starts acting up the instant we get to the top of the attic stairs, and she whips out her inhaler and takes a few hits. The cinnamon apple candle is surprisingly bright, or maybe our eyes are just getting used to the darkness. We walk across the beams to the far end of the huge, dusty attic, to where there’s an actual floor. There are a few boxes of old stuff here. Baby photos, my first pair of shoes, my mom’s old sewing machine. Jill grabs a Good Housekeeping magazine from the 1980s and plops into the wooden rocking chair to read it as I dig through a box.

“Oh my god, look at their shoulder pads!” she squeals. I hold up the candle and giggle at the big-haired models with jeans pulled up to their belly buttons. Jill rocks backward and a loud snapping noise makes us both freeze.

“What’d you do?” I ask.

“I don’t know. Did I rock onto something?”

She leans forward, bringing the curved legs of the chair with her. The candlelight reveals a broken slab of wood on the ground.

“Get up,” I tell her. “There’s something here.”

Jill pulls the rocking chair out of the way so I can see better. The piece of wood is like a latch to a trapdoor. I didn’t know there were two ways to get into our attic.

“It must lead into my parents closet,” I say, trying to envision the layout of the second floor below us. But that can’t be right. I look over to the patched-up hole in the middle of the attic where their bathroom is, and their closet is right next to that.

“Open it!” Jill says. “It’ll be like opening the hatch on Lost.”

I never watched Lost so I don’t know what she’s talking about. All I know is that this could keep me from being The Boring Friend, so I pull the rest of the broken latch away from the trapdoor and pull it open.

3 Answers

Relevance
  • ?
    Lv 7
    9 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    You know what? I wish there was more. That's how much I like it. I also mean I wish there was more in this way.

    Here are a few things:

    I think there could be a little more elaboration on the condition of the house at the beginning. Maybe another example or what the first thing a visitor or passerby might notice.

    I would love more than just you saying it started to rain. That could be a whole little scene. Maybe you didn't have time or space for it. But we could learn more about your characters here.

    I do learn about the dynamics when Jill seems to be trying to manipulate the narrator.

    I like the attic, you took me there. But I think I would hear rain on the roof a lot louder than the rest of the house. And have you ever smelled an old attic?

    One of the things I like best here is you have a voice. There is a consistency in the narration and to me, that is one of the most important things in writing.

    Thanks for sharing.

  • Anonymous
    9 years ago

    Boy! Thanks for making me feel oh so old, and in a musty, falling apart way, not vintage. lol

    Generally speaking, I'm all about starting the story at the inciting incident - that moment in time when the protagonist's normal life disintegrates under her feet. This works for me in a way though. I suspect it might work better with an inciting incident, but this reminded me of a train pulling out of a station (in the olden days.) It starts slow and picks up steam. Mostly? You left us right when it picked up full steam, which is always a good place to leave someone. lol

    One of the advantages of being old (in a musty, rotting away kind of way lol), is I caught something off. You misstepped on an era. Bell bottoms were out by the end of the 70s. It was all about straight legs (or worse - stirrup pants or jogging suits) in the 80s. I think the women were going for the look of a ladle - all about the width of the spoon/hair, but the handle had to be super skinny. (No shame there. I was old in the 80s, too, so didn't do the hair thing. I got old early. lol)

    Weaknesses and strengths? You have a tendency to stick too much tell in your show. You do show, but that's more like an add on to the tell. Oddly, you're good at show. Trust that about yourself, and you'll skip the need to tell, too.

    There is something else about this that strikes me odd, but please remember I really am old. Present tense, but not quite. Sorry, it's been decades since I took Latin, so I don't remember some of the odder tense. I think this qualifies as past preset or present past. Either way, it's narrated like it is happening a little bit before it is told. It happens today, yet is told like it's after it happened. I'm not really sure if that's right or wrong, but it is different from what I know. If it's intentional, keep it. There is strength in doing the abnormal when you know exactly why you're doing it. It really just could be me...because I'm smelly old. lol

    It is something. (I judge writing by the David Letterman guidelines - whether it's something or nothing. Yours is something. lol) Worth working on, and possibly continuing. As is, it's an interesting character sketch.

  • Anonymous
    7 years ago

    difficult thing browse at search engines like google this can help

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.