Wdyt about feminine names with boyish nicknames?

I like it a lot. Most of the time it can be seen as cute and spunky!

I dislike the practice because I sort of see it as a counterproductive measure. What I mean is, what's the point in going out of your way to choose a beautiful, feminine and elegant name for your daughter, only to entirely undermine the decision by giving her a, likely, shorter mannish nickname that will no doubt catch on with pretty much everyone in her life.

On the other hand, I don't really see anything wrong with it and, indeed, would prefer if people chose feminine first names and masculine nicknames. And if you do like masculine nicknames for girls then the first little paragraph I wrote doesn't at all count for you.

All in all, it's OK by my standards, but only if it's an obvious masculine nickname rather than a forced one. For example, I HATE "Charlie" for Charlotte - Charlotte may be the feminine variant of Charles but that doesn't excuse the fact that Charlie and Charlotte sound nothing alike. Something along the lines of Alberta "Bertie", Georgetta "Georgie" or Wilhelmina "Will" would be better and more appropriate, in my opinion.

Georgie

Andrea (Andy) or Miranda (Randy) ~ Miranda Alexandra or Alexis (both Alex) ~ Alexandra (Alexis is a boys identify) Danielle (Danny) or Donatella (Donny) ~ Danielle Charlotte or Charlene (each Charlie) ~ Charlotte Kendra (Ken) or Natalie (Nat/Nate) ~ Natalie Josephine or Joannah (each Jo, Joey) ~ Joanna spelt competently Georgia or Georgina (both George) ~ Georgia Harriet (Harry) or Mathilda (Matt, Matty) ~ Mathilda Nicole or Nicolette (both Nick) ~ Nicole Samantha (Sam) or Theodora (Teddy) ~ Samantha Valerie (Val) or Victoria (Vic) ~ Victoria Veronica (Ronny) or Julia (Jules) ~ Julia Francesca (Frankie) or Stephanie (Stevie) ~ Stephanie Frederica or Winifred (each Fred) ~ Frederica Maxine (Max) or Regina (Reggie) ~ Maxine Jacqueline (Jack) or Christina (Chris) ~ Jacqueline Antoinette (Tony) or Rachel (Ray) ~ Rachel Wilhelmina or Willow (each Will) ~ Willow Roberta (Rob, Bobbie) or Judith (Jude) ~ Judith Callista (Cal) or Alessandra (Les) ~ Alessandra top three favourites: Victoria, Joanna & Rachel 3 least favourites: Frederica, Maxine & Mathilda i do know you did not ask however listed below are the nicknames i might use for some of the names you provided: Andrea ~ Drea Alexandra ~ Alexa Danielle ~ Elle Donatella ~ Donna/Ella Charlotte ~ Lottie Natalie ~ Tally Josephine ~ Jo/Josie Joanna ~ Jo/Anna Georgia ~ Georgie/Gia Georgina ~ Gina Mathilda ~ Tilda Nicole/Nicolette ~ Nikki Samantha ~ Sammy Theodora ~ Dora Victoria ~ Vicki Stephanie ~ Steph Frederica ~ Erica Winifred ~ Winnie Jacqueline ~ Jackie Christina ~ Chrissie/Tina Rachel ~ Rache Wilhelmina ~ Mina Judith ~ Judy Calista ~ Callie Alessandra ~ Sandra

I don't mind Josie, but Frankie and Georgie are corny on a girl haha.

I'm really not too crazy about boyish nicknames on girls:( I just think that a boys name should stay as a boys name and a girls name should stay as a girls name. However, if a girl turns out to be a tomboy, then i think masculine nicknames would be ok :)

I like them, except for "Frankie." That just seems too boyish Lol

It would depend on the name to me :p

I like Charlie as a nickname for Charlotte but I don't like Frank as a nickname for Frances. I also like Sam as a nickname for Samantha :)

I think they are very cute! Some I don't like, but the three you have listed, I love! ♥

It can be cute. My manager's name is antoinette but everyone calls her toni