Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Affirmative Action And Extremes?
OK, here is a question for liberals (mostly) of Affirmative Action...
If a company's racial profile has less that 77% whites, are they guilty of discrimination against whites? The 2010 census shows the US population at 77% white, so if you are speaking of "fairness" then companies can only have 13.1% non-white employees to be "fair".
If you have more, yoou are discriminating against whites.
What is to prevent people from following the pure statistic? The truth of the matter is that no matter what, there is a higher percentage of the population that is white, so basic math prevents a balance in numbers. We have to get to the point where we base our decisions on skills and compatibility. If you have two candidates with equal skills and education, but the white guy is the better fit in personality, why is that a bad decision? Will it always be a racial issue?
** Please note: There was a degree of silliness to this question, just as there is silliness to the "fairness" desired by many on the left. If I ever get to a position of hiring (in my own company or another), I want to be able to hire based on the person themselves--not their race, gender, whatever.
11 Answers
- ?Lv 78 years agoFavorite Answer
My medical practice is 33% black, and proud of it! While two of us are white men who were covered by trust funds and scholarships all through school the third is a sharecropper's grandson from Mississippi whose entire family worked multiple jobs so he would have the chance to rise that I was born with.
Until you understand how much harder it is for a black man to get into medical school from an underfunded public education system, without legacy status or proper financial support, you wull not understand why affirmative action makes the difference it does.
Be grateful your parents were not Mississippi black, and make room for others who were not as dumb lucky in the genetic sweerstakes.
By the way, two of our kids fell in love and got married, so the grandchildren will have trusts of their own and legacy status at Harvard. Not bad for the great great grandchildren of slaves. Affirmative action allows the talented to be upwardly mobile, just as the American Dream would have us believe.
- ArnieLv 78 years ago
"The trouble with our liberal friends is not that they're ignorant; it's just that they know so much that isn't so." Ronald Reagan
The Liberal ideology is a theory which holds forth beliefs that have no basis in reality.
They are Advocates of a policy that empowers a strong government to enslave its people with a high tax burden incident to the support of extravagant and unnecessary social programs destructive to both the work ethic among the lower class, and the incentive to innovate and succeed among the working class.
The problems we face today are because the people who work for a living are outnumbered by those who vote for a living.
A democracy will continue to exist up until
the time that voters discover that they can vote themselves generous
gifts from the public treasury. From that moment on, the majority
always votes for the candidates who promise the most benefits from
the public treasury, with the result that every democracy will finally
collapse over loose fiscal policy
A broken government can't be fixed by the same government that broke it.
@
- Truth is elusiveLv 78 years ago
Any affirmative action is a form of discrimination. Some discrimination is helpful such has been used in the past to level the playing field. Some discrimination is not such as requirements that demand less qualified individual be selected to fill quotas. Some is just stupid such as the NFL rule that every team with a head coaching vacancy has to consider an black person even when they are just going through the motions.
- George SLv 78 years ago
No. Discrimination is only what white people do against others. It doesn't exist in the other direction. White people just deserve that because they are white.
They were really unfair to the rest of the world by adopting rationalism while the rest of the world remained with romanticism. That allowed them to race ahead of formerly more advanced cultures.
Now they must pay for "cheating" like that by being forced to conform to romanticism until they fall into line with the rest of the world.
Source(s): For decades I studied philosophies, cultures, and social institutions. I began that because of confusion resulting from my military experience under the shadow of neo-Marxist anti-military and anti-capitalism indoctrination in the universities. I continue a forty year quest wading through the huge pile of stinking crap a wide variety of bigots dumped on top of truth hiding it from nearly everyone's view. The pile was made by blaming people or practices they don't like while excusing people or practices they do like regardless of where the fault really lies. - ?Lv 78 years ago
Quota programs are mandatory in SOME government offices. Private employers may voluntarily adopt quota programs, but they don't have to.
In either case, the quota is determined by local or regional demographics, not national, so your 77% figure wouldn't apply.
Also, AA programs are not just used for race and gender. They are also used for the disabled and veterans.
- ?Lv 68 years ago
Affirmative Action is just another way of keeping track of certain groups of people without all the political racial allegations.
- SummertimeLv 78 years ago
All that stuff is caved and staved up in your mind to make it mean something. White women are the chief beneficiaries of Affirmative action. Its stats. But you probably don't care about that fact.
- Anonymous8 years ago
This is a rather dumb question, as you could get completely different answers if the company were in Detroit or if it were in Cheyenne.
- Anonymous8 years ago
You need to quit worrying about crap like that. You are young, don't let this race thing eat you up.
- Spock (rhp)Lv 78 years ago
oh -- whites can't be discriminated against -- only liberal approved races, creeds, and cultures can be discriminated against.
Source(s): grampa