Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

What do you think about statutory rape laws?

When I was 14 I had consensual sex with a 20 year old man. My moms' boyfriend was a cop. He found out we had sex and pressed charges. Very soon after he went to jail my mom broke up with her boyfriend and she forced me to go to counseling which I didn't want to go but she made me. Everyone talks about how he took advantage of me when he didn't. I am 20 now and I look back and see I was mature enough to consent even though I was below the arbitrary age of 16. What do you think about statutory rape laws? Can't they take maturity into account as well?

Update:

@Genegee: It was not the correct thing to do. I loved him.

Update 2:

@Squid: We can have a maturity test that does not involve machines.

Update 3:

But there is no reason to make us wait.

Update 4:

@Josh: Just like we determine when someone is too drunk to consent. That is not subjective. We determine whether an adult is incompetent and needs a guardian.

Update 5:

@laslo: He was not praying on me. Now that I'm 20 and look back this is what I really think.

Update 6:

@wendy c: I am not a poster child. I felt I was mature at 14. Most of my friends weren't but everybody matures at different rates.

Update 7:

@hotwheels122287: In many societies throughout history you were considered an adult at 14 or 15. I oppose the idea of an arbitrary age and to take MATURITY into account. "Teenager" is a modern invention and the body was made to have sex and reproduce at the end of puberty. If a 14 year old is mature enough to make an adult decision then they should be allowed to.

11 Answers

Relevance
  • lucy
    Lv 7
    7 years ago

    At 14, you was not in love, but you was infatuated with him and most likely excited that a much older man was interested in you. For a 20 year old to be involved with a 14 year old, does not make sense, since in effect he had sex with a "child". Now that you are 20, what happened to him? Did he ever contact you when you became an adult, or has he been involved in another child? (pedophile)

    Where I have a problem with the law, is when for instance a minor, say for instance age 15 gets pregnant with a guy over 18, they get married, but the guy is still charged with statutory rape. Some of these guys have a pedophile record, that most likely never should have.

  • Anonymous
    7 years ago

    To determine whether someone is "mature" or not is subjective. What one considers mature another person considers immature. So the law establishes an age at which one can reasonably expect adequate consent to be possible. Sure some teens are mature before that age while others remain immature after that age. But that is the minority of situations. In the majority of situations the opposite is true. So the laws are in place to prevent adults from taking advantage of minors.

    EDIT: A 14 year old who is having sex with a 20 year old is most likely compensating for something his or her parents are not providing her, or is sexually abused . We have these laws to deter and prevent predators from taking advantage of these youth

  • ?
    Lv 7
    7 years ago

    At 14 a child cannot consent to sexual act. The maturity has nothing to do, it was set up to protect minors under the age of consent. What would a 20 years of age man do with a child 14? ^^ That perturbing..

    No you did not love him you were infatuated with him. As an Adult he knew better than to have sex with you, he should have respected your age. He is considered a pedophile for having sex with a minor under the age of 16.

    Source(s): If this man had any feelings for you he would have waited.
  • Squid
    Lv 7
    7 years ago

    If there was a magic machine that could measure maturity, of course that would be best for everything from sexual consent to drinking, to voting and gun ownership.

    But there's no magic machine, so instead we pick an age where most people will be mature enough. Of course it's possible that you were an exception. There will always be some exceptions. Even at your current age of 20 you could probably find someone who isn't mature enough yet.

  • 7 years ago

    there is no such thing as consensual sex when you are a minor under the age of consent.

    yes he did take advantage of you regardless of whether you think that or not, he was the adult of the situation, he knew the laws, and he chose to break them.

    i think the laws are there for a reason. no 14 year old should be allowed to make such an adult decision. and no, maturity has nothing to do with it and still shouldnt.

    there are PLENTY of reasons to make kids wait!!! dont try to say otherwise!

    edit: oh sweetie.... what delusions you hold in that head of yours.... we arent talking about other cultures or things of that matter.... if you are in the USA the law says you cannot consent. thats all there is to it dont bring anyone else into your sad abused story.

  • .
    Lv 7
    7 years ago

    The LAW says you are not mature enough to consent. The LAW put him in jail.

    You rant on about maturity and all that, but consider this - if you were really all that mature, you would have known the laws (and so would he), and the ramifications of the laws put into place, and you both would have said no.

    So you've pretty much blown your own mature theory out the old window, lol.

  • ?
    Lv 7
    7 years ago

    You cannot legally consent at age 14. A 20 year old preying on 14 year old girls has problems that you apparently do not yet understand. The statutory rape laws were made to protect underage girls like you but they have no way of giving you any common sense.

  • 7 years ago

    It is called statutory rape and your consenting had nothing to do with it, you were under 18 years of age. That law was put there to keep older more experienced people from taking advantage of young inexperienced people.. Your mothers boyfriend did the correct thing by arresting the older guy. That is my feelings in this matter.

  • 7 years ago

    They are silly. Interestingly for most of the time we've had age of consent laws the ages have been 12 and under. There also have never been any studies or research done that shows that a child is incapable of consenting to a sex act. But the law is the law.

  • ?
    Lv 7
    7 years ago

    if you really believe that then you still have the mentality of a 14 year old. statutory rape laws don't go far enough.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.