Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Prove that as n -> ∞, this becomes Cos(x)?

Let k = 4n, where n = positive integer.

Let a = x + √(x² - k²) and b = x - √(x² - k²). Prove that as positive integer n -> ∞,

(1/2) (1/k^k) (a^k + b^k) -> Cos(x)

Check out plot of both functions for n = 10, a small number:

http://i254.photobucket.com/albums/hh120/Scythian1...

Update:

Eugene, fix your 3rd line, 4n = x/y, not x/4y

Update 2:

Eugene and Pauley Morph, both of your proofs reference the complex form of Cosine. But the neat thing about this expression (1/2) (1/k^k) (a^k + b^k) is that it yields a real polynomial with rational coefficients. And it can generate very accurate values of Cos(x) very fast even for "large" x > 0 values.

Update 3:

Indica, you fixed Pauley Morph's problem. He should have used θ = arcsin(x/k).

4 Answers

Relevance
  • Eugene
    Lv 7
    7 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    lim(n -> ∞) (1/2)(1/k^k) (a^k + b^k)

    = (1/2) lim(n -> ∞) [(a/k)^k + (b/k)^k]

    = (1/2) lim(n -> ∞) ([x/(4n) + √((x/4n)^2 - 1)]^(4n) + [x/(4n) - √((x/4n)^2 - 1)]^(4n))

    = (1/2) lim(y -> 0) ([y + √(y^2 - 1)]^(x/y)) + [y - √(y^2 - 1)]^(x/y))), letting y = x/(4n)

    = (1/2) lim(y -> 0) (exp{x • ln(y + √(y^2 - 1))/y} + exp{x • ln(y - √(y^2 - 1))/y})

    = (1/2) lim(y -> 0) (exp{x • ln(y + √(y^2 - 1)/y} + exp{-x • ln(y + √(y^2 - 1))/y})

    = (1/2) (exp{x • lim(y -> 0) ln(y + √(y^2 - 1)/y} + exp{-x • lim(y -> 0) ln(y + √(y^2 - 1)/y}

    = (1/2) (exp{x • lim(y -> 0) 1/√(y^2 - 1)} + exp{-x • lim(y -> 0) 1/√(y^2 - 1)}), by L'hospital's rule

    = (1/2) (exp{x • 1/i} + exp{-x • 1/i})

    = (1/2) (exp{-ix} + exp{ix})

    = cos(x).

    @Scythian thanks for spotting the mistake.

  • ?
    Lv 7
    7 years ago

    Note that ab = k^2 where k = 4n is an even integer.

    So (1/2) (a^k + b^k)/k^k =

    (1/2) (a^k + b^k) / (ab)^(k/2) =

    (1/2) ((a/b)^(k/2) + (b/a)^(k/2))

    Since n, and therefore k, is going to approach infinity, we may

    as well write

    a = x + i√(k² - x²) and b = x - i√(k² - x²) with |a| = |b| = k

    Then we can assume that

    a = k exp(i θ) and b = k exp(-i θ)

    where θ = arccos(x/k) for large enough values of k.

    Then (1/2) (a^k + b^k)/k^k =

    (1/2) ((a/b)^(k/2) + (b/a)^(k/2)) =

    (1/2) (exp(i k θ) + exp(- i k θ)) =

    cos(k θ)

    I was doing great up to here and then things fell apart

  • ?
    Lv 7
    7 years ago

    For large enough k let x/k=sin(α) so α→0 as k→∞

    Writing x={ sin(α)/α }{ kα } and taking limits as k→∞ gives x = 1*lim(kα) = lim(kα)

    From definitions of a & b, a/k=exp(i(π/2−α)) and b/k=exp(−i(π/2−α))

    ∴ ½( (a/k)ᵏ + (b/k)ᵏ ) = cos(k(π/2−α)) = cos(kα) since k is a multiple of 4

    lim cos(kα) = cos( lim(kα) ) = cos(x)

    If k=4n+1, 4n+2, 4n+3 the limit is sin(x), −cos(x),−sin(x)

  • Anonymous
    7 years ago

    That's a pretty powerful function you have there.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.