Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

donpat
Lv 7
donpat asked in Yahoo ProductsYahoo Answers · 7 years ago

Why has my TOP Contributor Designation been taken away in such a disturbing and unfair manner?

I give well-organized, detailed, and correct answers. I include equations with proper symbols and show the proper units. Many askers fail to select a best answer. My badge top contributor symbol has been missing from my answer picture for a long time. This lessens my chance of having my answer selected a Best Answer. When my answer is selected a Best Answer, I usually get five stars for my answer.

My participation in Yahoo Answers is an important part of my life. I put a lot of time and effort into giving top quality and correct answers. I often get only two points for an hour of work; same as a token

answer submitted.

I am 74 years old and retired after being a teaching engineering professor. Yahoo Answers participation and getting Best Answers are an important part of my life. The recent difficulties

and frustrations with not getting Best Answers and losing my Top Contributor designation have

been very depressing and discouraging.

Please look at the quality of my submitted answers. They are all worthy of a Best Answer. I put a great deal of time and effort into Yahoo Answers.

Why can't my Yahoo Answers be posted to my Facebook page, like was possible some time ago?

4 Answers

Relevance
  • ?
    Lv 7
    7 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    It happens to us all & I can understand why you say it is unfair.I lost my 3 TC due to the new format causing most of my contacts leaving YA.They regularly gave me BAs in the categories I frequented,sometimes up to 20 each day.Now I an lucky to get 2 per week.Although a TC doesn't mean much,it does signify that our answers are appreciated by other members.I got most of my BAs in Education & Referrence sub sections.The fact is,without those BAs our BA percentage falls and we lose the badge.

  • 7 years ago

    To actually answer your question, your TC status was not removed in any unfair manner, sorry. That badge is not based on the quality of answers nor is it passed out upon review of a person's contributions. It is based strictly on a numerical algorithm. Enough Best Answers in a single category in a certain period of time and you get it. That's it. If you answer in a category where people seldom choose the Best Answer, it will disappear. Now that YA has terminated voting, I suspect many, many users will lose theirs, as many users depended on voting to maintain it.

    Sorry that you find this disturbing, but since this change affects everyone across the site, it is totally fair. You simply need to accept that the site isnow different and not hang your sense of self esteem or self worth on something as trivial as the TC crown.

  • 7 years ago

    It is all about helping others not getting best answers. BYE!

  • Anonymous
    7 years ago

    from one of your comments: "The quality of the answer should be given consideration."

    the quality of the answer was never given any consideration in the old green format or in the new format before voting was eliminated

    TC was ALWAYS based on the quantity only of answers you gave in a particular category, up to three categories

    in that regard, nothing has changed

    what has changed is due to the elimination of voting, we ALL now receive less BAs and many have lost their TC crowns

    there is no reason to alter your participation in YA just because a gold crown no longer appears beside your avatar

    no one is going to discount your answers

    since most people were and are aware that TC status was about quantity rather than quality, most don't pay any attention to it - you pick the best answer, not the best answer given by a top contributor

    it would be absolutely impossible for Yahoo to create computer code that would be capable of reading every single answer posted and determine the QUALITY of the answer and dole out TC crowns based on the content of the answers - absolutely impossible

    that's why it's calculated on the quantity

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.