Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Do Jesus and Mohammed have the same God and the same God salvation concept?

Update:

Unlike Islamic claim, ALLAH in Quran had NO PERSONAL NAME concept YHWH (=I AM), then it is hard to claim ALLAh in Quran and YHWH in the Bible are the same being

Update 2:

ALLAH in Quran ordered to bow down toward the black stone in daily worship but YHWH prohibited this action.

Update 3:

Unlike the Islamic claim, the Allah concept was limited in 1 dimension as 1 divine being behind a veil in high sky (like 1 super man on earth) meanwhile Jesus revealed His God concept is NOT limited in any dimension: He existed with the Father before the world was created, and He also emphasized the Father and the Son are ONE. Then the issue is .... Who, Jesus or Mohammed, is the truth about God?

Update 4:

For Jesus in the Bible, Jesus himself called SATAN is who denied or rejected his death and resurrection in his God salvation plan, can His teaching apply to Allah in Quran when this being denied God salvation in Jesus?

Attachment image

13 Answers

Relevance
  • 6 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    NO although Mohammed claimed the same god for his goal. In fact, they are NOT the same GOD at all b/c each faith clearly had their own different God, Sin, Salvation, Heaven concepts and their own prophets.

    The Bible exposed the Quran modified and corrupted many Biblical stories for Mohammed's view and his Arab pagan worship way later. Surspringly, Jesus in the Bible also called and exposed Allah in Quran as a bogus, disguised god, or Satan who denied the death and the resurrection of Jesus in the Bible.

    Note that all claims in Quran had NO artifacts and NO Witnesses at all.

    Moreover, unlike the holy and just creator named YHWH In the Bible, Allah in Quran was an unholy and unjust creator who was the greatest deceiver and created evils and sins to people (Q 3:54, Q 113:2, Q 4:78,...) for his temptation test purpose..

  • DS M
    Lv 6
    6 years ago

    It is baffling that Islam is about 2000 years older than Christianity, why there is zero evidence of Islam's first 24 prophets among any of the Arab governments and religions. Equally as puzzling is why Allah was unable to compile the Quran using the prophet who wrote is credited for bringing us the scriptures orally?

    Since the angel squeezed Muhammad until he was able to read, one would think that after the angel left he should still be able to read at least that text...but there is no evidence of that. It has to be a bit disappointing to tell others that you read but wasn't given the text to show others the miracle while there is no evidence he ever read a second time.

    It would make sense that the angel squeezed literacy into Muhammad so he would write AND compile the Quran...but that didn't happen. So the Quran was compiled a couple of years after Muhammad died and because Abu was afraid that Allah made a mistake by not compiling it.

    Today, we have a copy of Hafsas copy...not Muhammad's...because the Muslim problem with women didn't exist until Aisha (who wrote 2210 hadith) led an army against Ali and lost . In addition, Uthman hadn't utterly wiped out all history of the previous prophets while leaving everything pagan untouched.

    So no, because of the radical changes that occurred in Islam after the prophet died, it is impossible to compare the two.

  • Anonymous
    6 years ago

    Jesus and Mohammed DO NOT have the same God and DEFIANTLY NOT the same salvation concept

    Islam is not all that they tell you it is so first and foremost, seeking out the truth about Islam and Muhammad.

    About Muhammad:

    Muhammad is a self proclaimed prophet. Muhammad recognizes the prophets of the Old Testament and the New Testament and presents a claim to be of the same prophetic lineage. However, Muhammad contradicts the prophets of both the Old and New Testament in countless ways. And unlike the prophets before him coming along, he in not of the descendants of Israel.

    About Allah:

    Allah as described in the Quran is not the same as the God who is revealed in the Bible.

    God of the Bible will not lie or deceive - Allah has no problem with lying or using deception.

    God of the Bible loves all of mankind - Allah only loves the Muslim.

    God of the Bible is absolutely pure - Allah not so much

    About Quran:

    The Quran is supposedly the revealed word of Allah but there are so many verses that insight violence that it is not funny. The New Testament in comparison, there is not one verse that insights a reader to violence, not one.

    About Jesus:

    Jesus you will find to be a very, very different sort of person. He was Godly, loving, giving and yet He was untamed, radical, a bit wild and certainly not one for the status quo; He was different. Look at the Bible and what it says about this man Jesus.

    Jesus did not do circus tricks; he would not perform miracles to prove he was from God. The only miracles He did perform were to meet the needs of those around him, healing the leper, restoring sight to the blind, raising the dead etc. But he did not pander to governing or the religious authorities of the time who wanted “a sign from heaven”.

    Some from within the Jewish religious authorities tried to set traps for him but He saw through there duplicity and turned the traps around and left those who came to set the trap, questioning their own motives. He was a friend of the outcast. He hung out with tax collectors, the down trodden the helpless, and the “sinners”.

    Christian Salvation:

    God came in the very person of Jesus taking upon Himself the likeness of a man. This man Jesus loved like no other and he was righteous like no other. In His love he took upon Himself all the sins of the world and died in our place. It was he who picked up the tab, he who took upon Himself the inadequacies of us all and it is His love that sets us free. Turn to Jesus and he will set you free.

    Islamic Salvation:

    It is all about a balance of scales. Do enough good deeds and pray enough to counter the sin in your life and maybe you will tip the scales your way and you will get in.

    About Muhammad again:

    “Watch out for false prophets. They come to you in sheep’s clothing, but inwardly they are ferocious wolves. By their fruit you will recognize them. Do people pick grapes from thornbushes, or figs from thistles? Likewise, every good tree bears good fruit, but a bad tree bears bad fruit. A good tree cannot bear bad fruit, and a bad tree cannot bear good fruit. Every tree that does not bear good fruit is cut down and thrown into the fire. Thus, by their fruit you will recognize them. - (Matthew 7:15-20 NIV)

    Seek the truth and the truth will set you free:

    See: https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=John+...

  • ?
    Lv 7
    6 years ago

    I think perhaps you haven't read the Qur'an, if you think Allah is not Yahweh. If you had read the Qur'an, you would know that Muhammad refers quite often to Abraham, Lot, Noah, Moses, and Jesus, all of them being servants of Allah. Further, he frequently makes it clear that the Jews and Christians, although they have a few things totally wrong, are following the same god. No, Muhammad never uses "Yahweh", but his god is clearly the god of the Jews and Christians.

    Muhammad described God differently in some cases, but that doesn't mean it's not the same god. According to Christians, Jesus departed significantly from Jewish tradition. Does that mean he's not a servant of Yahweh? No. Same god, different ideas about what he wants from us.

    Obviously, no, Islam and Christianity do not have the same salvation concept. Again, read the Qur'an. It says many times that Jesus is NOT God's son, Jesus is NOT God, God is NOT part of a trinity. The Qur'an says if you believe these things you are an idolater and you will go to hell for eternity.

  • Anonymous
    6 years ago

    Of course Jesus and Muhammad have the same God and the same God's 'Salvation' concept. But Paul rewrote the Gospel of Jesus and called it 'Bible' to justify/promote his innovated teachings as per his whims and wishes.

    Its either you follow Jesus' teachings and be the beloved of God, by following Islam today, or go to hell, following Paul's teachings, who had never met Jesus in his lifetime.

    The Choice is yours.

  • 6 years ago

    Salam Yes Jesus and Muhammad and also other prophets have the same God that is Allah swt and the same salvation concept by obeying all commands and prohibitions of Allah as stated in the holy book supported by hadiths

  • 6 years ago

    Jesus didn't die for anyone's Sins

    He died because the Jews killed him.

    God said you will all be accountable for your own sins and he is the only person who can forgive you.

    Muhammad was a prophet just like all the other prophets who was sent on this earth to give the message of the Quran to people as well as be an example to people on what they can do in certain situations that can happen in life.

    That was all.

    Both grew up in two different countries and Muhammad lived longer than Jesus.

  • 6 years ago

    Absolutely NOT. Check out their Holy Book.

  • 6 years ago

    Read the Qur'an

    Noah, Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, David, Moses, Jesus and Mohammed (AS) all preached the same core message of Islam. To submit one's will fully and completely to the Creator alone in obedience and worship. To make no partners, associates, sons, or daughters with Allah. That is the straight path followed by all the prophets.

    The prophets said 1 God alone. No son, no daughter, no wife, no cousin. Christians however say something completely different from the prophets. They manufactured their own separate theology. 3in1 God, original sin, salvation by grace, abolished divine law, sacrifice innocent man god for crimes of sinners, God died for 3 days. As you can see, the beliefs of Christians are disconnected from the message of monotheism and submission of the prophets, it is different theology. On the day of judgement, this foundation of falsehood and polytheism is rejected and hellfire is the abode unless one repents and submits.

    I invite you to Islam, to submit your will completely to the Creator alone. It is the truth, even if you dislike it.

  • ?
    Lv 6
    6 years ago

    Interesting concept.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.