If insurance companies controlled the gates of Heaven would anyone be let in?

only those with paid up policies

Absolutely...how else would those companies pay for the pearly gates if not with fees by those they let through the gates?

Instead of asking people to spell "Love" the masses would probably be asked to spell "Czechoslovakia" before the Gates would open. In other words the price is often higher than what they will dispense to you. The only insurance one has, is the assurance of Jesus Christ; those gates swing open as he is the key to life!!

If they get a profit for rejection no

I shudder at the thought.

New customers would be let in. They LOVE new customers....

for what would it profit them to lose the entire world just to gain one soul. my guess is no.