Michael G

Match these guys up however you want too, also imagine all six are in their primes and at their best. Who advances to the finals, the championship and who wins it all , give the winner to each fight as well.

1- Shane Mosley

2- Oscar de la Hoya

3- Felix Trinidad

4- Ike Quartey

5- Floyd Mayweather

6- Manny Pac

In order they have 1- floyd 2- manny 3- Paul Williams 4- Marquez and 5- Chad Dawson

I guess my biggest problems with this is #'s 3-5, what i dont understand is both Mosley and Marquez last fought floyd and both got beat badly how does shane go from #3 all the way to #9 and Marquez also from #2 or 3 only gets knocked back to #4. I personally would still have shane ahead of Marquez maybe in top 5 , I would also probably have Martinez in the top 5 as well , what does everyone else think ... who would your top 5 P4P fighters be at the moment?

If Floyd could land a fight with Paul Williams in march, what kind of statement would he be making? Also who do you like to win that fight at 147 or 154? I think he should push for a williams fight because otherwise Manny is gonna have Floyd looking pretty foolish when he fights Clottey and Floyd ends up fighting some lesser/smaller fighter again. Floyd could never really be criticized again in my opinion if he were to face Willaims in his next fight and then Mosley in may ( assuming he beats berto).

Cotto vs Trinidad (current/and/or prime)

Cotto vs De La Hoya (current/and/or prime)

Cotto vs Mosely - rematch (current/and/or prime)

Cotto vs Mayweather

Cotto vs Hatton

I personaly think Cotto is extremly overrated, dont get me wrong i like cotto a lot i think he is a good fighter and exciting to watch but i think he still has a lot of questions to answer as far as how good he is. I mean everyone whining about mayweather not taking a fight with him but what is Cotto really doing to better himself or get a shot? Choosing to fight gomez then mayorga are poor decisions on his part and wont prove anything unless of course he happens to lose to one of those bums. If floyd wont fight him yet why is he not chasing the other top welterweights meanwhile to earn his shot? I dont just mean the figthters i listed im talking margarito/cintron/williams etc. I personaly think he would lose to everyone i listed in the question with the exception of hatton i think he would destroy hatton. Opinions?

I really hope this doesnt happen , I mean really what would be the point. After the de la hoya rematch , theres talk of mayweather going out to manchester to fight hatton. Mostly due to hatton whining about the ref in their first fight. Also cause I guess mayweather feels he would be making history to go over to wembly stadium to fight him and do what he did in vegas to ricky again. I think its a terrible idea for him to even consider that , it will only hurt Floyds carear not help him. Everyone is tired of Floyd ducking certain fighters. Oscar proved he deserved a rematch regardless to what fans think he lost a split decision therefor should be a rematch not to mention the money that will be made. Hatton did nothing to suggest he deserved a rematch and hes not even in mayweathers league. I would like to see floyd give de la hoya his rematch then fight mosely ,then give margirito and cotto a shot. Then he can go and retire and if he beats them all that should silence all his critics.