What do you think of 14 yr old girl who threatened President Bush online & got a visit from Secret Service?

In Sacramento CA, 14 girl old freshman took picture of President Bush & wrote Die on top, drawing dagger through heart on MySpace.com. Secret Service found it & visited with her parents, took her out of class & "poor baby" says they were mean & yelled at her.
She threatened the President of the United States what did she expect. I tried to warn everyone it was a federal offense, but it continues on here all the time.
In this world of school shooting who can tell the real threats from the stupid statements. Outcome still unknown.

I am 51 & it has always been a federal offense, the political party does not make a difference.

2006-10-14T16:33:12Z

Ash - How are we suppose to know she is "just talking" - all but one of the school shooting posted threat or told others. They all thought they were "just talking". So was it OK for them to shoot the students.

Russ - This is no new law made or newly enforced by President Bush - it is became US law in 1948.

mister2-15-2 Considering the reaction of her parents & the fact they raised her, it is easy to realize they could not be trusted to remind her firmly that it is wrong to threaten the US President or anyone for that matter. I did not find them to be very concerned with what she did just that SS had talked to her.

Shelley - they do not need permission to question a person who is threatening the President . Age does not enter into it. Teenagers are becoming the fastest growing group of violent crimes.

Great answers & many thought proking ideas. Hope our teachers are watching closely when threats are made, all have proved to not be groundless threats

Anonymous2006-10-14T07:35:07Z

Favorite Answer

They were right in questioning her. Where does one draw the line between a legitimate threat and a mere rant? It is one of the primary jobs of the Secret Service to investigate such things.

At first I thought they were wrong in doing it at the girl's school. But the way the girl's parents are making noise about this it was better that they did. They most likely would have stopped the agents from talking to her without a warrant or lawyer. Then it would have been a long, drawn out process. This way they were able to talk to her and close the file. (Besides she learned her ideas from someone.)

Carissa2016-05-22T05:17:47Z

I think that because it was a "threat" towards the president, that it is justified... I don't know if I believe completely about what she was saying about how they were treating her during questioning though... And I do indeed think that her parents should have been present during the questioning. Because we are in a war time environment, the president and secret services do need to be looking out for things like that... She did remove it later, which was definatly a good idea, but she shouldn't along with anyone else have posted that on there... As for freedom of speech, which one person put on here about how republicans are trying to take that away... it is not true... especially in this case... your freedom of speech is only your right when it does not inflict on someone else's rights... Research helps...

Anonymous2006-10-14T07:49:26Z

It is good to see the Secret Service has so little to do. Personally I would think a call from the local government or police to her parents would have sufficed. Perhaps the Secret Service needs the publicity. Now I would be real concerned if the send the child to Guantanamo. She just might be a dangerous enemy combatant. Then maybe terrorists groups are outsourcing some of the job to teenage girls. The Bush people have great imagination when terror is involved and might exploit this to show the desperation of terrorists. If there is a political advantage the Bush people will find it.

timm17762006-10-14T07:25:49Z

Once the secret service determined that the "threat" came from a 14 year old girl, I don't think tax dollars should have been wasted on a trip to give her a stern talk. A call to her parents or the local police might have been more appropriate.

I DO think the girl should have been held accountable for her actions. Set aside your partisan preferences for a moment. Making threatening images like that is a serious matter. I wonder how she would have felt, and others on this site would react, if another student had posted a similar image about her?

ItsJustMe2006-10-14T07:43:30Z

It is a federal offense, and since she did it online, there was no way for the secret service to know if she was a harmless little girl, or a wacko posing as one.

I think every threat should be taken seriously until a full investigation is conducted. You never know - she could have had a home-made bomb or a gun from her parents and tried to actually harm someone. Glad the secret service took the threat seriously.

Everyone has freedom of speech, but threats and hate speech are not permitted.

Show more answers (26)