did i get ripped off?

this is my other trade, i gave up a rusty roy oswalt, a hot 18 game hit streak nate mclouth who plays for the pirates so i figured now would be a good time to trade him, and a 1st rounder for a injured but when healthy superstar alfonso soriano and a up and down pitcher mark beurhle

Chuckie G2008-04-21T16:59:33Z

Favorite Answer

I think this is a pretty fair trade-Soriano is expected back as soon as he's eligible to come off DL, Oswalt might be better and Mclouth may or may not keep this up. Two gambles for a pretty sure thing.

Anonymous2008-04-21T16:41:32Z

Yeah I think so. Mark Beuhle is not up and down he is just down right now and Soriano's injury could reduce his production this year so if these guys don't come through you got ripped off big time.

lecharley112008-04-21T16:35:02Z

i really don't know