Does Anyone else think that Carlos Quentin is vastly underrated and without a doubt be an All-Star?

Favorite Answer

so far this year he deserves to be an all star but he is only underrated because what has he done in the past? I think he is playing way over his head and will cool down the second half of the year...Show more

I aint going to pretend I'm too familiar with Haystacks Calhoun, I have looked up a few of his matches after hearing about him, on youtube, but you can never get the full aspect of one's career by watching odd matches because research lacks emotion His style reminds me most of Uncle Elma, slow and basic but a hell a size to look at. For the time he will have been an impressive sight but to mention vader who is very athletic for his size doesn't do Haystacks Calhoun any favours to be honest, tho he's definately more impressive than Abdullah the Butcher. Someone who I have to mention is Bam Bam Bigelow. This guy in the 80s was rolling around flipping cartwheels and high flying like a crusierweight and as a heel was a real bad @ss and scientific wrestler who knew how to work his opponent's body parts to set up for his flying headbutt....Show more

I don't think he was underrated because you heard about him as he came up through the Diamondbacks and how good he was going to be. The only problem that Quentin had with the Diamondbacks is that they already had really young outfielders coming up and Carlos Quentin became avaliable because of the emergence of Chris Young and Justin Upton. Furthermore the Diamondbacks are going to be kicking themselves for trading away another outfielder and that is Carlos Gonzalez of the A's....Show more

He deserves an all star nod, but, I don't know if he is underrated. The Diamondbacks would disagree, and I am for now. He did practically nothing for his first two years in the league with Arizona, so I think he is over achieving right now. That should not discredit his numbers this year and his all star worthiness....Show more

The guy has monster numbers and he, along with Dye, are raking the ball. But, since the All-Star game is more about popularity than numbers in some cases I doubt he would get elected even if he was on the ballot this year. . .which I don't think he is. Definitely deserving and has the numbers to back that up....Show more