To All Baseball Fans - re: players acquired by your favorite team?

Of all the trades (or free agent signings) your favorite baseball team has made since you've been a fan, what player did you hate the most while he played for ANOTHER team, but you loved him when he was with YOUR team?
Answers can go back as far into history as anyone's memories will take them.
Thanks in advance to all who answered.

Y!A's Apex Predator2009-05-15T00:46:32Z

Favorite Answer

Milton Bradley, Never really thought much about him thought he wasn't that great or whatever then when the cubs got him I love him lol hoping he will help out the cubs in the playoffs all though I personally would've rather had Adam Dunn than Bradley

Alex H2009-05-15T16:24:02Z

As a Tribe fan here's my favorites

Favorite Trade- Bartolo Colon and Tim Drew for Grady Sizemore, Lee Stevens, Brandon Phillips, and Cliff Lee or Kenny Lofton and Alan Embree for David Justice and Marquis Grissom

Favorite Signing- Roberto Alomar in 1999

I hated Juan Gonzalez when we faced the Rangers, but I loved what he did in one season for the tribe.

D2009-05-18T08:25:14Z

Well, I can do the opposite of that easily enough. I loved Andruw Jones, and was excited when we picked him up, but then hated him as he proceeded to torpedo his career.

Finding someone I hated then liked when he became a Dodger is tougher. I think I'd have to go with Kevin Brown. He did amazing things for us, and gave us the first legitimate ace since Orel Hershiser. Then he went to the Yankees and imploded, and you could only watch in disgust.

?2009-05-17T17:51:09Z

Amazing how no one said Rickey Henderson.

I hated when he stole so many bases against the Red Sox, but liked him when he played for us, even at the twilight of his career.

Rocco Baldelli is another pick.

<=MCRFAN=>2009-05-18T11:50:02Z

Johnny Damon and AJ Burnett

Show more answers (14)