Removing surface roots without harming tree?

I have a couple pine trees in my yard, both are about 40 feet tall. Not sure exactly what kind they are, but one is pretty much a normal looking, straight up, short needle fir tree. And the other one branches off alot, looking somewhat like a cactus, and has needles roughly 2.5 inches long.

They both have a few surface roots popping up in the lawn that I'd be interested in getting rid of. Now I did a bit of research on the web, and almost every page I stumbled upon was highly against it, saying it could kill or severely harm the tree, or make it fall in a windstorm. It kinda scared me a bit, however none of those sites really mentioned any of the factors as far as how many roots are removed, how big, how far from the tree, or in what length of time.

So I'm wondering, is there a safe way to remove a couple roots without harming the tree? For example, I've spotted one surface root on each tree that I'd consider as one I'd like to see go. Each one is about 1.5 to 2 inches in diameter. One I'd like to cut back about 10 feet from the one tree, the other one I'd like to cut about 5 feet from the other. Would cutting such a small root off each tree really stand a chance of harming it? Aren't there hundreds of other roots, that each tree won't miss one small root?

Couldn't I cut those couple small ones (one from each tree), and wait a couple years before thinking about doing any more so the tree can recover? Or would those little 2" roots still have a drastic effect?

oil field trash2009-10-16T18:41:13Z

Favorite Answer

You can usually cut a root on a tree without harming the tree permanently.

The loss of one root will not keep a pine tree from tipping over in a windstorm. They are shallow rooted and prone to that problem. We've had three of them do that in the last 5 years at our house.

rmbrruffian2009-10-16T19:07:43Z

1.5 - 2 inch diameter roots are NOT small roots. Those are major roots and you will do serious damage to the tree if you cut them.