What's with all these weak stereotypes about the sign Cancer these days?

Look back in the literature, or consult somebody who actually knows what they're talking about. Cancer is NOT the sign to show weakness or be a needy crybaby. Not even close. For some reason, pop culture has made them into these weak little people who will tear up over any little thing right in front of you. If you're deeper into astrology, you will know that this is NOT the case.

Cancers have often been portrayed as the most emotional sign of the Zodiac, which is quite possible, I suppose. However, they always hid their emotions. Cancers were known to act tough and be diligent in hiding their feelings. They're often the type that will do all they can, including acting mean on the surface to avoid showing their feelings. They're a lot like Scorpios, except perhaps not as dark or mysterious, and more straight-forward in toughness, but all with good intent. I suppose that they sounded too close to Scorpio for some, but without the dark image... Which led to the whiny, pathetic stereotype. They took the emotional part and ran with it, and forgot all about the part that a CRAB HAS A SHELL. Which makes Cancer one of the toughest on the surface. It's just ridiculous that people think of this sign as one that is as sensitive as Pisces on the surface, only more emotional. This sign is tough because it knows it can't afford not to be dominant from the get-go. If anything, they are much more like Scorpios than Pisces.

And the whole thing about being clingy??? That makes no sense, because Cancers are secretly afraid that they won't be accepted, and they will NEVER make the first move in a relationship. What they are most afraid of is being seen as too caring, too weak, or too coming on too strong. And a Cancer will never admit hurt, need or weakness. If anything, they'll act more bitter and cold. This just really bothers me, these ridiculous stereotypes. This is not the way the Cancer sign really is. It's almost as bad as calling goths emos, if you catch my drift. Does anyone else have this issue, and realize the way Cancers really are?

2009-10-25T14:32:54Z

By the way, as you may have guessed, I am a Cancer sun with moon in Virgo and Sagittarius rising. I myself never cry in front of others. I am always 'okay.' Ironically, I find myself holding composure for the likes of Aries, Pisces, and Taurus on a daily basis. I had the guts to go up and give a whole-hearted talk about an extremely close relative at a funeral, without blowing my composure or shedding a tear, while many others (who weren't even as close) cried their eyes out, trying to talk after I did. I'm not saying there's anything wrong with that, because there isn't, but I'm merely demonstrating how uncomfortable Cancers are with showing emotion. My 11-year-old cousin (also a Cancer) went up and talked about his grandma without a tear, just as I did. Honestly, that must show something.

2009-10-25T14:48:39Z

Janie, that's just passion more than anything. I was kind of worried someone might take it like that. I don't mind though.

Love you to death2009-10-26T04:26:11Z

Favorite Answer

OMG im so impressed with your stuff about cancers... Yes! it is so true... we're not at all the way we're stereotypes... finally someone proved it in a right way... im glad to finally hear something like this about us... even im the same... no one really think that im emotional... they literally laugh if say im a cry baby and sensitive and emotional... i almost look like a crazy pretenstious freak!... and i like giving such impression than being myself to everyone... generally people see me as a very bold and confident girl... i hide all my fears inside and could manage to be tough, sometimes arrogant person i could... i can count the people with whom im the real me.. i always protect myself and intentions within myself... wow i really liked your question and you exactly described us in a pretty nice way!... i hold my tears in any situation... infact i hate crying infornt of others... and i can say im the most toughest women around... coz i learn from my experiences and over come all my fears... so im neither sensitive nor pathetic emotional... im feeling good about myself after reading something like this... thanks !.. great question..this is the best question so far i've seen about cancers in this horoscope section

ranay2009-10-26T20:02:40Z

Well I'm a very emotional Cancer and I can't help it. So they got that part right... so what? But I'm not clingy and I don't depend on others for every little thing... I don't need people around 24/7 and I find it a bit draining. I'm OK being with myself, reading a book while eating Ben and Jerry's ice cream.

It's very annoying with almost every book describe us as moody whiners, extremely dependable and all that other crap. The nicest thing they say about us is being 'motherly' and 'caring' while other zodiac sings has something so alluring about them.

On the surface, if I don't know you, I come across unemotional and seem distant...oops that sounds like a certain air sign, does it? I don't think that generic astrology books will ever change the description of Cancerians any better soon. I realize that people do have similar traits in themselves like their sun sign and I know some people that have a few dead ringers (I already mention with myself).

But like you said, there is more than the general horoscope labels they place upon us. I have a Sag Moon and wouldn't MIND hearing the truth if it helps me in the long run although it will hurt to hear it (Cancer feelings again) and a Capricorn ascendant that makes me unreadable and distant to those I'm not close to to.

We are the underrated underdogs and we are far from WEAK. We are the ones that most people will run to or keep things together when everyone else falling apart.

Anonymous2009-10-25T17:08:26Z

Since you want to use few examples of ppl to illustrate a whole then I'll say I met someone with Cancer rising and Cancer moon, and she fit the clingy, emotional, moody description to a T. She whined the world was cruel when all she ever did was make ppl happy and she suffocated the ones she loved, BUT she didn't cry (never ever. only in front of select few but after being under very stressful moments) and neither was she weak (even if complaining she wasnt breaking down). Don't assume that having certain attributes makes you by default have others.

Crying doesn't make someone weak. It shows that you care enough to make it emotional. Being emotional isn't a sign of weakness, but a sign that you're human and that you CARE.

Also, if all of sudden I act bitter, cold and detached because I was hurt doesn't that make me emotional? It does.Because if you were cold and detached you wouldn't have turned into something vile to protect from perceived attacks. It wouldn't bother you.

I admire ppl that cry openly without fear or regret. I admire the Cancer ppl that are truthful to themselves and never afraid to admit caring for someone or trying to be with them no matter what. Takes a lot of courage to expose yourself like that. Someone that can be vulnerable to others is truly someone strong! They know they won't break even in if exposed.

maverick2009-10-25T15:01:32Z

Agree with you . River Person.
I do see lot of budding astrologers or people who read the first 10 pages of books or some basic junk astro sites and come out with the deduction that since moon (emotional lead) rules Cancer hence cancer has got to be the most emotional sign of all.
Basically, its much more than that astrologically.
Every placement of Planet / Every house / Every transit of Planet / Every aspect of planets creates a web of action that cannot be generalized.
In my view, every planet creates emotions subtle or blown out / said or unsaid / hidden or exposed.....

Overall, In my view those signs like pisces etc (dualistic) are always tricky and sensitive when it comes to the emotions part.
Interestingly these signs are generally the most affected by the aftermath of the emotions (once its passed)....!!

No offece to anyone ....just my personal thoughts !!

Anonymous2016-04-10T05:53:02Z

Loss of appetite can mean a lot of things, from catching a cold to cancer. The possibilities are too many, and with the limitied information you provided, it is hard to determine what the cause it. However the chance of it being cancer is rather low. I would suggest you to take her to see a doctor, though. Whenever in doubt, always visit a doctor... seeing the doctor early can save lives!

Show more answers (9)