Do you take a 1 loss Alabama in a rematch over Boise State?
Lets start with the assumption for this what if, that Stanford and Oklahoma State both lose a game. Alabama and Boise State are not getting in over an undefeated BCS Conference Champ.
Key wins:
Alabama - Arkansas, Auburn, Penn State
Boise State - Georgia, TCU, Air Force (Triple Option wild card team)
Key losses:
Alabama - Lost to LSU at home while not scoring a touchdown, the only team LSU held to less points was a FCS team BUT to be fair LSU was equally inadequate on offense against the Tide. Georgia Southern, though technically not a loss and most likely a massive blowout, any team that chooses to schedule a FCS team should have that game counted as a loss. To be clear if they had a game cancellation or if they didn't have every team begging to play them this would be excusable.
Boise State - Boise didn't schedule any cream puffs but they do have a weaker conference schedule than most BCS conferences outside MAYBE the Big East. If the BCS lovers are right and the regular season is a playoff, than you need to lose to be eliminated (No such thing as a win every game and you lose playoff). So if we had to assign Boise State a loss it would be, not being invited to join a BCS conference earlier LOL
Something you probably didn't know about each team:
Alabama - Can still win the SEC West if Arkansas defeats LSU. It would come down to the team with the highest BCS ranking to get in since they would be in a 3 way tie. LSU losing at home on the last weekend would probably bump Alabama past them.
Boise State - According to the Sagarin rating system (the most commonly used SOS index) Boise State actually had a tougher SOS than Alabama or Stanford going into last weekend. Ironically the reason Alabama didn't plummet in the computer rankings after the loss was because the game against LSU bumped their SOS up so much that it offset the loss (Going 8-1 against a top 25 schedule is about equal to going 8-0 against a schedule that barely broke the top 40).
Questions to ask yourself:
Do you really put a team that already lost to the LSU at home back into a rematch at LSU (BCS Title Game is in Louisiana)?
Do you really put a non AQ in the finals!?!?!
Is winning your conference a requirement in the supposedly reformed BCS? (Much has been made of the debate on whether you should have to win your conference, let alone division to get a shot at the National Championships).