well im a die hard fan of the .357 magnum...i own a "4 inch Colt Python but the other day a friend of mine and myself were arguing over who had the better gun...he has a Glock in 10mm and he was saying that his gun was "waaaaay" more powerful and better than mine...so we tested them out and shot a bunch of things like phonebooks, watermelons, metal plates, and a wall....my .357 magnum did more damge in all our tests but he still wont shutup.....basicly im gonna ask you people which gun you think is better his Glock 10mm or my Colt Python .357magnum....which one would you take out of these two and why???????
2013-03-07T13:08:38Z
Mine is a 1973 Colt Python with a "4 barrel...he has a brand new Glock 20 10mm
Dot Com2013-03-07T20:04:09Z
Favorite Answer
I'm so jealous of your Colt Python!! My favorite gun!!! I own a Ruger GP 100 (.357 magnum) and a Glock 20 (10mm). And I would say as a round, the .357 magnum is better.. I have done countless testings with both rounds and I can honestly say that the .357 mag came out victorious in almost every aspect.. It penetrates much better than a 10mm. It's easier to find, and cheaper.. Most 10mm rounds available are under-powered.. Only a select few are loaded to their full potential, and those are very pricey. On the other hand, the cheap Winchester .357 mag is loaded very hot to almost as high as the top 10mm. The only thing the 10mm has going for it is that you can carry more rounds because it's a pistol cartridge.. My Glock 20 holds 15 rounds, while my Ruger holds 6. I could go on and.. But like a said, as a round, the .357 magnum is superior! However, in a gunfight, I would probably take the Glock because of the extra rounds (even though you may not need them, but you never know.. lol). Hope this helps..
You are comparing a $500 glock to a $1400-$2300 dollar Colt. Colt ALL the way! Besides, comparing a 10mm to a .357 mag is like comparing a .40 to a .44 mag. No comparison, just look at the cartridge size, the .357 is HUGE compared to the 10mm. I would choose my Colt Python over my Glock any day of the week.
In terms of who has the better gun, you could have stopped after typing "Colt Python." You win then and there, IMO.
Regarding the .357 vs the 10mm, I answered a question about this just the other day. Commercial off-the-shelf loads are all over the map, but for the most part, the muzzle energy is roughly equivalent between the two. However, SAAMI specs allow for a higher maximum pressure from the 10mm, so in theory, that round can be loaded to be more powerful. Your Colt may well use the powder charge more efficiently than his Glock, however, so if you were to chronograph each gun with the hottest load you could find, your Colt may well come out ahead.
Unfortunately, when we talk about a gun being "powerful," we are probably more interested in knock-down power than just raw energy. Both the .357 and 10mm are fairly likely to shoot all the way through a human target--especially if they're loaded to their maximum potential. Any energy that remains once the bullet exits the other side of the target is wasted. So, we have to look at what kind of damage was done prior to that. Unfortunately, his 10mm is going to leave a bigger hole than your .357 (~9mm).
If you want to bring reliability into the conversation, the Glock is arguably the most reliable semi-automatic handgun in the world. However, as well-engineered as it is, it still cannot match the rugged reliability of a well-made revolver, and your Colt is most definitely that. I'll wager that your gun is the more accurate of the two by a fair margin, also. Where you might have the edge in accuracy, you certainly lose in capacity, though.
As I hinted at before, if value comes into the conversation, the Python wins hands-down. Even in rough condition, I wouldn't trade your gun for two of his.
His Glock is an obvious winner for accessories, or being tacti-cool. I don't even like to consider that factor, since the accessories available for a gun really have nothing to do with the quality of the gun itself. Still, he may have the sizable backstrap and palm swells and all that, and there IS more customization that can be done to his gun without going to the gunsmith.
For the record, I really wanted your Python to come out ahead. I'd choose it over the Glock any day. They're both great guns, there's no doubt, but this is like comparing a finely-crafted sailing yacht to a sleek powerboat. At the end of the day, they're designed for the same thing, but they take drastically different approaches to getting there. Congrats to both of you for owning some fine guns, though.
Edit: Hey, there we go! Matt makes an excellent point. Your Colt can take .357s, .38 special/+P/+s, .38 longs, AND .38 shorts, with varying degrees of success. Let's see his Glock do that! You win.
You can buy Glock 20s all day long. But you will not often find a nice Python at a price most people would pay. That Python if it has no issues is CLASS as real as it gets in the world of great firearms.
No Glock can compare to the quality of that Python. See any plastic on the Colt ? 'nough said.
Edit : I think I would suggest an accuracy challenge to settle this question. Yes sir, someone is going to loose their watch. Watches at 50 '.
Which is better ? Personally, I would take the Glock...and I have both. ( not the 20...the 21 ) The 357 doesn't have a safety, no slide to work and hold 6 shots. The Glock has a great safety system, a slide to work...but with that safety, you can safely carry one in the chamber and simply have to squeeze the trigger ...and you can do that 15 times.....more accurately and faster than a D/A revolver. Ballistically, the 10 packs more punch. Yes the 357 will take 38 ammo for target / more economical shooting, but I think there is a 22LR conversion available for both the 20 and 21. It comes down to personal preference...do you want the old school wheel-gun or a relatively light semi-auto that packs a lot of punch ? Ask your buddy if he wants to trade me...if I could do it again...or afford to buy another pistola right now, I would have the 20...hands down. ( and I'm not a diehard Glock-a-holic, either )