Why is it generally considered OK to ban fully automatic weapons, but not Constitutional to ban semi automatics?
2019-09-17T18:53:47Z
Under the NFA, it is illegal for any private civilian to own any fully automatic weapons manufactured after May 19, 1986. Only certain types of gun manufacturers may make them, and then only for purchase by qualified state and federal agencies. There are no exceptions.
USAFisnumber12019-09-16T20:19:28Z
Actually the ban on full auto has not been challenged in the Supreme Court.
The 2nd Amendment is based on the Age of Enlightenment notion that humans possessed the innate rights of self defense and self sufficiency. One of the oldest principles of Constitutional law, however, is the notion that one person's rights end when they infringe upon the rights of others.
In arguments related to personal arms, the key factor is the potential for indiscriminate damage and danger for those in the immediate area. This is the same principle as applied to things like hand grenades and bazookas.
In short, your right to defend yourself against an attacker or target a particular animal as game should not infringe upon the reasonable rights of those in the same general area to their own personal safety and property.