Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

F(x) = definite integral of Sqrt(t^2-9)dt on [4,x]. Find: F(4)?

We're supposed to use part of the fundamental theorem of calculus here:

If f is continuous on an interval I, then f has an antiderivative on I. In particular if a is any point in I, then function F defined by

F(x) = S f(t)dt [a,x]

is an antiderivative of f on I; that is, F'(x) = f(x) for each x in I.

The book tells me it's zero... but I really have no idea why.

Update:

PLEASE READ THIS DETAIL BEFORE ANSWERING!

I realized after posting this quetsion that the function IS actually:

F(x) = indefinite integral of sqrt(t^2+9)dt.

That doesn't explain to me why F(4)=0.

Update 2:

on [4,x] still

Update 3:

thanks for defining academic disohonesty for me.

when you get off your high horse, you can re-read the question and notice that i already know the ANSWERS because they are GIVEN to us! in fact... the university gives us access to the solutions manuals for our text books FREE! SO-- asking for help on a problem that 1.) I have already been given the answer to and 2.) is not GRADED (because honestly, what calculus professor would knowingly assign us problems that we already have the answer to and then grade them?) is not considered cheating.

Why don't you go pick on the middle schoolers who post every single one of their alegbra questions?

Good day.

Update 4:

ps purplepentode -- it's clear you didn't even read the details because then you would know the function is really sqrt(t^2+9).

Update 5:

I already said we don't submit this as homework.

We don't have "homework" that is graded. If it is graded, then it is not an assignment in the book, as we alreayd have eveyr answer to every question the book.

I didn't ask my professor, because she's already gone home for the day. This is a six week calculus II course. I don't have time to wait a day for an answer. I do as much as I can during her office hours, and then I finish the rest on my own, which has resulted on a total of three occasions in my asking a question here on Y!A. Every time I've asked a question, I've LEARNED something, because people (yes, even people like you) have the kindness to explain things to me. (and last time I check, I wasn't the one on the high horse, since I'm asking such an ELEMENTARY =P question and NOT cheating because none of this is GRADED.).

Ok. Thanks.

3 Answers

Relevance
  • 2 decades ago
    Favorite Answer

    because, when you evaluate a definite integral over the interval [a,b] you take the anti-derivative evaluated at a and subtract from it the anti-derivative evaluated at b.

    in your example, the interval is [4,4] which means the integral is taken, evaluated at 4, then evaluated at 4 again and the two (identical values) are subtracted.

    in other words, 4(x)- 4(x) = 0, where x = anything.

  • 2 decades ago

    If this is a homework problem that you're supposed to work on yourself, then asking this question here constitutes academic dishonesty (cheating).

    Let's assume it's a simple Riemann (Calculus 101) integral, and that it is being evaluated over a t interval of zero length (from 4 to 4). If the integrand has no singularities in the vicinity of 4, then the integral is well defined (its upper and lower limits at the interval end points are equal) and has value zero. You must check this condition on the integrand because if it isn't met, the integral isn't defined even if the interval endpoints are identical.

    The function sqrt(t^2-9) is indeed well defined and continuous for |t| .ge. 3, so the conclusion is as stated.

    One way to "see" that the answer is zero is to go back to the definition of the integral (in terms of upper and lower sums of step approximations). For example,

    F(x) =(approx) (x-4) f(4) (lower sum)

    =(approx) (x-4) sqrt(7)

    which converges to zero as x converges to 4.

    ---------

    If this still doesn't convince you, then by using trig substitution and integration by parts, you can show:

    integral[sqrt(t^2 - a^2)]dt

    = (t/2)sqrt(t^2 - a^2) - ((a^2)/2)ln (t + sqrt(t^2 - a^2)) + const.

    If you're taking a calculus class, it's worthwhile to derive this. Perhaps inability to do this derivation is what you mean by, "I really have no idea why."

    It should then be clear that the indefinite integral is well defined in the the vicinity of t=4, and that the definite integral from [4,4] evaluates to zero.

    -------------

    Before YOU get on a high horse, the proper person to ask your question is your teacher, and if you submit any of the answers given here as your own without proper attribution, then it is cheating plain and simple.

    -------------

    If the integrand in question is actually sqrt(t^2 + 9), then the solutions I offered are actually even simpler to obtain. The indefinite integral provided most recently needs to be changed, but since you're following this, I'm sure you'll be able to handle this without any difficulty.

  • 2 decades ago

    The area under the graph from x=4 to x=4 is 0.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.