Who should have won American Idol from the auditions to now in your opinion?

Well American Idol is a rather peculiar thing is it not? Some of the best ones get voted off for minor mistakes that lets face it are inevitable in every new career especially without proper training... I think Paris and Kellie were two very good singer and well they still will put out albums but I just think its funny that they got voted off. Now Chris who stayed longer than those two sings alright but does not sound original. He sound like so many rock singers in the past 6 to 10 yrs. I was not highly impressed and every song he sang sounded the same....So, Now down to Taylor or Kathryn?...I think I can picture Kat in Vegas singing her little heart out and making people in love with her, or singing for Walt Disney movies... but as far as buying her album well we'll see...Taylor Hicks is original and has a sound that we all have not heard or seen for a long time...MORE power to him and I think he will win and I think he deserves too. See I hate to be the one that says this but if you put the demographics into play the winners went like this white female, black man, black female, and then they saw what was happening and said **** it looks to obvious to let a white man win so lets fix the show results and let the white woman win and then the white man can win next year and it does not look like a demographic thing...But ok face it is has been... Anyway said my peace about the show.

loyal fan

We Need Someone who will bring New Songs And More Attention To The Public For Entertainment! I don't think Kat Will Bring That To Us That Why I Voted For Taylor?!

I was hoping it would have come down to Chris and Taylor, but it didn't. I like Chris alot, but am happy with Taylor winning as well.

Katherina has a great voice and is very pretty, but I just don't think she can pull it out.

Chris Daughtry!

George W. Bush

God Bless America!

Chris by all means!!! He rocked the house. But I like Taylor too!

I picked Taylor in the auditions....

Mandisa

I'd be happy w/ Chris, Elliott or Taylor.

Chris, but I would be happy with Taylor.