Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Anonymous
Anonymous asked in Society & CultureReligion & Spirituality · 1 decade ago

Some people in shia cumunity think that Anita Rai is superb writter other thinks she is an Agent.Is it true?

he mainstream Muslims, their organizations/institutes, especially the ones in my part of the world, i.e., the ‘West,’ are busy trying to respond to criticisms of Islamic ideologue they perceive as harsh, bigoted and unjust, particularly the concept of Jihad and the personality and actions of their Prophet, Muhammad. They do so with stale arguments, that are tailor made, too convenient, too conventional, and taste like chalk, hoping to get the Muslim conscience on trial, off the hook. Muslims are busy in explaining away all question marks directed at their religion, with dry, too-neat and too-cold theories; with quotes from the Quran they are comfortable with; with little sermons justifying in an Islamic way every precept held under the international microscope – and of course, with ahadith, traditions. They always fall back upon their precious treasure house of hadith to clarify their positions and policies, grievances and grudges. While they cry and clamour that the Islam under international scrutiny is ‘not real Islam,’ they fail to demonstrate ‘Real Islam.’ They have never been able to come up with a foolproof, relevant and enduring blueprint of what they suppose is ‘real Islam’. And those Muslim socialists and idealists who have the impression that something is truly wrong with the tenets of Islam itself opine that these need to be addressed and remedied before too late.

3 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Some people in shia cumunity think that Anita Rai is superb writter other thinks she is an Agent.Is it true?

    he mainstream Muslims, their organizations/institutes, especially the ones in my part of the world, i.e., the ‘West,’ are busy trying to respond to criticisms of Islamic ideologue they perceive as harsh, bigoted and unjust, particularly the concept of Jihad and the personality and actions of their Prophet, Muhammad. They do so with stale arguments, that are tailor made, too convenient, too conventional, and taste like chalk, hoping to get the Muslim conscience on trial, off the hook. Muslims are busy in explaining away all question marks directed at their religion, with dry, too-neat and too-cold theories; with quotes from the Quran they are comfortable with; with little sermons justifying in an Islamic way every precept held under the international microscope – and of course, with ahadith, traditions. They always fall back upon their precious treasure house of hadith to clarify their positions and policies, grievances and grudges. While they cry and clamour that the Islam under international scrutiny is ‘not real Islam,’ they fail to demonstrate ‘Real Islam.’ They have never been able to come up with a foolproof, relevant and enduring blueprint of what they suppose is ‘real Islam’. And those Muslim socialists and idealists who have the impression that something is truly wrong with the tenets of Islam itself opine that these need to be addressed and remedied before too late.

    You are: islamic Your Answer: Yes many people think like this. they are not only ignorant but they cannot take the truth. What Anita has written no body has done so far. She has shown mirrrrror to muslim who Degrade their prophet by lowering him down. Source(s) Anita Rai’s new book • MUHAMMAD: Uncovering the True Story

    Anita Rai says…

    Muhammad: Uncovering the True Story does not claim to be his biography, as life of Muhammad [saw] cannot be captured in the space of a book. Whosoever claims to have written the biography of Muhammad [saw] is not being honest to himself/herself and to his/her task.

    For the Quraysh real source of discomfort and vexation was Abu Talib who along with his sons was keeping Muhammad safe and strong and the patriarch had called upon the whole clan of Banu Hashim and made them stand like ramparts all around Muhammad [saw].

    Sahaba & Sabotage uncovered!!!

    Strangely enough the Muslims did neither accompany Muhammad [saw] to the Sheb-e-Abi Talib, nor did they lift a finger in helping their beloved Prophet, during three long and difficult years of siege. Abu Bakr, Umar bin Khattab, Uthman bin Affan, Abdur Rahman bin Auf, and Saad bin Abi Waqqas, who later rose to places of eminence didn’t even bother to pay Muhammad a single visit while Muhammad [saw] and their benefactress Khadija relentlessly struggled for three years in the harsh gorges of Sheb-e-Abi Talib.

    Character Assassination uncovered!!!

    I say this with tremendous responsibility and care that a considerable number of hadith compiled by Bukhari, Dawood, Muslim, and Malik are misguiding and mischievous not to say disgusting in the least, in that they are murderous to the actual person, practice, preaching and purpose of Muhammad [saw].

    DREADFUL MYTH uncovered!!!

    My deep and unquestioned love for The Messenger of God have encouraged me also to take on the over-sensitive and controversial issue of his marriage to Ayesha bint Abu Bakr, while renowned Muslim scholars remain curiously silent allowing the flawless person of Muhammad [saw] to be abused most deplorably.

  • 5 years ago

    people shia cumunity anita rai superb writter thinks agenttrue

  • 5 years ago

    Islam & Quran is NOT about sectarianism and grouping. Quran is commanding something else and we are going 100% opposite. Islam & Quran is about purification of one's "self". سورة الشمس قَدْ أَفْلَحَ مَن زَكَّاهَا وَقَدْ خَابَ مَن دَسَّاهَا Al - Shams verses 9 & 10 Truly he succeeds that purifies it (self), And he fails that corrupts it (self)! I did try to ask legitimacy of their respective sect in light of Quran and instead proving from Quran, they have put me on block. They hear and listen the truth but they have closed their ears, their eyes and their hearts. They found their forefathers following respective sect, how can they leave or question their sect. Quran only approves the label "Muslim" as per last verse of Sura Al - Hajj. But we wear many more funny labels. Each & Every sect & group is invalid as per Quran. NOT a single verse that commands to create & form any sect. It would be a futile effort to ask them to discard their sect, whereas the reality is They Wont. Pedram (a shiite) used to write at the end of his answers. "Truth Speaks for itself........". I asked him as to which truth you are talking about BUT gentleman did have any answer to my question. Remember: Prophet Muhammad shall disown every sect & label as per Quran. I am sect-less and also never ever have associated myself with any sect or group and also never have tasted any label. I dont call myself a ahle sunnah wal jammah bcoz Quran only approves the label of "Muslim". I am just a Muslim and very very few appreciate this truth. :)

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.