Who is your favorite American Idol judge, Simon, Randy, or Paula?

I'd have to say Simon because American Idol would be nothing without him. I mean, can you imagine the show without his sarcastic comments?

Simon

I like Paula and Simon. Paula gives confidence and Simon is truthful.

Simon is The Man! he always say's the truth!

Paula (to me) looks like she over medicated on her Prozac,and Randy is cool but he's getting to skinny he needs to eat a Snickers Bar to keep it real!

I like Simon because he tells da truth straight up but sometimes i think hes too mean and sometimes hes wrong! my 2nd is randy then paula

i think of Simon is hilarious because of the fact he's so recommend. Paula is nice and her comments are oftentimes clever. Kara seems kinda dumb. And Randy is merely marvelous! I enjoyed it better with 3 judges, particularly provided that now all they do is argue, quite of being expert judges.

I really like SImon, he is honest. Paula tries to sugarcoat everything,Randy seems to do the same. Simon, open and to the point, no b.s. there...

simon doesn't bullshit... paula i think just wants to get in the pants of every cute guy that gets on stage, and randy just doesn't really know what to say because he's first every week.... simon tells it like it is, all the things that are wrong with the performance that maybe the viewer at home can't really define, simon defines them. he rocks.

100% SIMON!! Paula to wishy washy Randy always stays at a happy medium.. Simon tells it like it is!

Me too! Everytime I can't wait to hear the truth about some of the worst performances that I can't believe Randy and Paula like. Those two definintly (srry can't spell) are way too nice sometimes.