Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

ajn4664_ksu asked in SportsBaseball · 1 decade ago

What is your ultimate 25 man roster of current MLB players?

They can't fill a role they don't currently hold on there team, ie no Carl Crawford as a pinch runner or K-rod as a setup guy, if they are a backup on your team, they must really be a backup. You can form an AL of NL team and can set it up anyway you want to. Only rules are it has to be 25 guys and as stated they must fill the same role for you as they do for real. I'll give mine when the I pick the top answer.

11 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    AL Team

    My Outfielders Would Be - Carl Crawford, Carlos Beltran, Alfonso Soriano

    Designated Hitter - David Ortiz

    3rd Base - Alex Rodriguez

    Shortstop - Jose Reyes

    2nd Base - Chase Utley

    1st Base - Ryan Howard

    Catcher - Joe Mauer

    Bench - Mark Loretta, Geoff Blum, Endy Chavez, Ramon Castro, Damian Easley

    Starting Pitchers - Johan Santana, Jake Peavy, Brandon Webb, Justin Verlander, Daisuke Matsuzaka

    Relief Pitchers - Joe Smith, Cla Meredith, Pedro Feliciano, Mike Gonzalez, Mike Timlin

    Closer - Joe Nathan

  • 1 decade ago

    Starting Roster:

    1st Base: Albert Pujos

    2nd Base: Chase Utley

    SS: Jose Reyes

    3d Base: Alex Rodrigez

    C: Joe Mauer

    OF: Alfonso Soriano

    OF: Carl Crawford

    OF: Vladimir Guerrero

    DH: David Ortiz

    Rotation:

    SP: Johan Santana

    SP: Chris Carpenter

    SP: Roy Oswalt

    SP: Roy Halladay

    SP: Daisuke Matsuzaka

    RP: Joel Zumaya(Will make a great closer some day)

    RP: Akinori Otsuka(Torific Relief Pitcher, not a closer when Gagne is healthy)

    RP: Scot Shields

    RP: Dan Wheeler

    RP: Jonathan Broxton(Could start at closer for majority of teams)

    RP: Aaron Heilman

    Closer: Jonathan Papelbon

    Bench Hitters:

    Henley Ramirez

    Ryan Howard

    Bench Pichers:

    Francisco Liriano

    Felix Hernandez

  • 1 decade ago

    1. Jose Reyes - Mets SS

    2. Ichiro Suzuki - Mariners CF

    3. Alex Rodriques - Yankees 3rd

    4. Albert Pujols - Cardinals 1st

    5. David Ortiz - Red Sox DH

    6. Vlad Guerrero - Angels RF

    7. Manny Ramirez - Red Sox LF

    8. Mark Grudzielanek - Royals 2nd

    9. Brian McCann - Braves C

    Starters

    Johan Santana Twins

    Felix Hernandez Mariners

    Jason Verlander Tigers

    Roy Halladay Blue Jays

    Dontrelle Willis Marlins

    Closer

    Mariana Riveria Yankees

    Thats the best I can do here fella. I personally can't fill the rest of the rosters with 10 more backups that I know. I follow the Braves... I know their active roster but not those of most teams.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    c. Joe Mauer

    1b. Albert Pujols

    2b. Chase Utley

    ss. Jose Reyes

    3b. Miguel Cabrera

    Lf. Barry Bonds

    Cf. Carlos Beltran

    Rf. Vladmir Guerro

    p. Johan Santana

    p. Daisuke Matsuzaka

    p. Dontrelle Willis

    p. Roy Oswalt

    p. Josh Bekett

    closer. jonathan papelbon

  • 1 decade ago

    C: Joe Mauer, Brian McCann

    1B: Albert Pujols, David Ortiz

    2B: Chase Utley

    SS: Jose Reyes, Derek Jeter

    3B: Miguel Cabrera

    OF: Carl Crawford

    OF: Vlad Gurrero

    OF: Alfonso Soriano

    OF: Jason Bay

    IB/OF: Lance Berkman

    SP: Johan Santana

    SP: Roy Halladay

    SP: Chris Carpenter

    SP: Roy Oswalt

    SP: Francisco Liriano (when he was healthy, he was even better than Johan and so young too)

    RP: Justin Spier

    RP: Justin Duscherer

    RP: Juan Rincon

    RP: Aaron Heilman

    RP: Cla Meredith

    SU: Scott Shields

    CL: Francisco Rodriguez

  • 1 decade ago

    OF- Vlad G. RF, David DeJesus. CF, Barry B. LF

    Infield- David W. 3rd, Reyes SS, Utley 2nd, Pujols 1st

    Moyer C

    SP- Roy Holliday, Santana, Chris Carpanter, JustinVerlander,

    Felix Hernandez

    Bench- Marcus Thames LF, Josh Hamilton CF,

    Omar Infante SS, Victor Martinez C,

    Chris Gomez 1st, Mark Loretta 2nd

    Relief P- Joel Zumaya, Ben Sheets, Jamie Walker,

    Fernando Rodney, Justin Spier,

    Mariano Rivera

  • 1 decade ago

    c. Ivan Rodriguez P. John Smoltz

    1b.Albert Pujols P. Dontrelle Willis

    2b.Marcus Giles P. Pedro Martinez

    3b. Alex Rodriguez P. Randy Johnson

    ss. Derick Jeter P.Tim Hudson

    rf. Vladmir Gurerro Cl. Marino Rivera

    cf.Andruw Jones Dh. David Ortiz

    lf.Barry Bonds C. Brian McCann

    1b.Adam Laroche

    SS. Miguel Tejada

    3b. Chipper Jones

    rf. Jeff Francoeur

    Cf. Tori Hunter

  • 1 decade ago

    catcher- jorge posada

    pitcher- roy halladay, roy oswalt, brandon webb, mariano rivera, Joe Nathan, Eric Gagne

    1st base- Albert Pujols

    2nd Base- Robinson Cano

    S.S- Derek Jeter

    3rd Base- Alex Rodriguez/Troy Glaus

    CF- Torii Hunter

    RF- Ichiro Suzuki

    LF- Hideki Matsui

    Utility Outfielder- Andruw Jones

  • 1 decade ago

    Here Is my 25 man roster. For a NL team, becaue is just dont like using the DH position.

    My starting Line up

    1.Perez ss Mets

    2.Vizquel 2B

    3. lee1B

    4. Bonds lf

    5. Beltran rf

    6. A. Jones cf

    7.C. Jones 3b

    8. I Rodriguez C

    9. Zito p

    my other pitchers

    M Cain sf

    Halladay tor

    Santana min

    Carpenter Stl

    R Johnson Ari

    Bullpen

    Sao LA.D

    Street Oak

    Eyre Chi.N

    Rivera NY.A

    Hoffman SD

    Bench

    Delgado 1b

    PH. only Ortiz Bos

    M ALou NY.n

    ramirez 3bChi.N

    Renteria SS Atl

    Molina C sf

    well here is my team

    for sure this team can be really good.

  • Anonymous
    5 years ago

    I trust your record with some exceptions. commencing CF may be Andrew Jones, circulate Mauer to bench and put in Brian McCann as a substitute of Ivan Rodriguez, take out zambrano and beckett and replace them with Glavine and Maddux and perhaps upload Peavy for oswalt, perhaps upload sabathia and hoffman to boot.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.