Someone just offered me a trade McGahee and S. Holmes for R. Wayne and F. Taylor?

Its tough, seems like a good trade but i probably wouldnt take it, you seem to be pretty solid at both positions.. RB and WR

R. Wayne would be nice to have but you would have to give up a very solid back and a very solid reciever in Holmes to get him, F. Taylor is all but worthless really, he would do nothing but sit on the bench for you... probably about what J. Jones does and he's better than Taylor.

I would say hold onto what you got.

Not a bad trade offer, neither team gets really screwed in the end! Here's the deal though!

Wayne would STACK your WR's he is #1 in the Colt's offensive receptions and even if Harrison returns, Wayne is likely to remain at the top of the pecking order for a while. You would see touchdowns nearly every weekend from him. Holmes has had some good games yes...but he is no Wayne...You would be better off on that end.

It's obvious that you would loose steam on RB's though. McGahee is a work horse and very consistent at putting up 10+ points a week for fantasy teams where Taylor is garbage.

I would counter with one of your TE's instead of McGahee and if it is rejected then just shrug it off. You have a great team and Wayne would be a nice addition, but you will be fine if he stays where he is.

Good Luck

If you have mcgahee and holmes, DONT DO IT!!!

Look at your RBs, 3 great RBs, if you lose mcgahee, you will be pretty thin at the position becuase fred taylor can not come anywhere near filling mcgahee's void.

Your WRs are already great. Housh is one of the top 3 WRs this year without a doubt. Fitzgerald is also a great option. Holmes is also a rising star and most places like sportsline and espn rate holmes as a top 14 at worst WR and ive seen top 9 at best! So he is a great option.

Your team is so solid already that trading is not necessary. You are stacked at RB and WR and you don't have to worry about your team.

yea do it thats a good trade for you. Holmes and Wayne are close to the same but Taylor and McGahee arent close McGahee is way better

I think you shouldnt do it...you have a great team like that and F.taylor is getting less carry each week...you should try to trade one of your TE if you only need one...try to trade shokey for another WR