Is Hannah Montana really actually talented?

In my honest opinion, the girl CANNOT, in other any circumstances ACT or SING well. I mean, those are skills that could be developed, and I trust with her power performing genes that it would be--but her show right now makes her look untalented and useless.

Overracting can sometimes be a good thing, but when she tries to be funny in her show, and I've only watched because my four year old niece adores her--she kills the comedy. She kills her character... That girl needs an acting coach to keep her more subtle to carry out the intended effect of the script better.

:-)

Well lots of people think she's talented or else she wouldn't sell out concerts tickets in 11 minuets, have a show in Disney and release Cd's.

I'm not really a fan but Ive caught a couple of her shows, the normal Disney thing.

She can act

and she can defiantly sing,

shes a very talented young lady and I wish her the best!

I think she is - she's really funny in the show, and she CAN sing. So, I guess she fits the bill of being talented!! It's not me up there, and she is selling out shows like crazy!! Give her her due respect, and her 15 mins of fame!! I think she's great for the kids.....

yes i think she talented because #1 her voice isnt made by computer #2 she is a really good actress and #3 she and just telling you i am her #1 fan i know all her songs and the name of every episode.well hope i helped

NO! Is paris hilton going to be a good business person? NO! Just because Miley Cyrus has a talented dad does not mean she has talent.

Nuh-uh. She's okay i guess, as a singer and performer. Other than that she's pretty average to me, more like below average sometimes. Though i have to admit i hate her acting and songs and don't see how in the world she got so many albums sold. Besides, i think she's just another gimmick disney's trying to sell the world again .

No, she's strictly a Disney 'star'. She'll be long gone and forgotten in six months. And she's only there in the first place because of who her father is- i'm sure he bought her way in there. It's all a marketing ploy, and to impressionable teens it will work until they find someone else to package and sell to our youth. Her talent is equal to that of someone singing Karaoke who has their own stylist,

She got lucky because of who her dad is.

Obviously it is a good show on Disney for teeny-boppy kids to watch and I respect her for not going and being another Lindsey Lohan.

She may not be talented but she is a good role-model.

Not a fan of hers really,but she seems talented.

nope, just a famous daddy. i watch the show, and i listen to her cd only because everything made today tuned for my age group is trash. she not the best singer and actor (and dancer). and i seriously don't think she would have made it without her dad, but she's a better role model for young girls than other (not mentioning any names, but *cough* Vanessa *cough*). even though that one picture on photobucket where Miley Cyrus is naked has got me wondering how "Christian" she really is. but there's always haters and photoshop. so you really never know.

i also think that her co-stars, namely Emily Osment, Mitchell Musso, and Jason Earls, act way better than she does. and her dad is the worse actor of them all (sorry Billy Ray, but you should have stuck to your mullet and Achy Breaky Heart).